Distinguishing AGN Feedback Models with the Thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect

Skylar Grayson,Evan Scannapieco,Romeel Davé

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/acfd26

2023-10-03

Abstract:Current models of galaxy formation require strong feedback from active galactic nuclei (AGN) to explain the observed lack of star formation in massive galaxies since z~2 but direct evidence of this energy input is limited. We use the SIMBA cosmological galaxy formation simulations to assess the ability of thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (tSZ) measurements to provide such evidence, by mapping the pressure structure of the circumgalactic medium around massive z~0.2-1.5 galaxies. We undertake a stacking approach to calculate the total tSZ signal and its radial profile in simulations with varying assumptions of AGN feedback, and we assess its observability with current and future telescopes. By convolving our predictions with the 2.1' beam of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT), we show that current observations at z~1 are consistent with SIMBA's fiducial treatment of AGN feedback, and inconsistent with SIMBA models without feedback. At z~0.5, observational signals lie between SIMBA run with and without AGN feedback, suggesting AGN in SIMBA may inject too much energy at late times. By convolving our data with a 9.5'' beam corresponding to the TolTEC camera on the Large Millimeter Telescope Alfonso Serrano (LMT), we predict a unique profile for AGN feedback that can be distinguished with future higher-resolution measurements. Finally, we explore a novel approach to quantify the non-spherically symmetric features surrounding our galaxies by plotting radial profiles representing the component of the stack with m-fold symmetry.

Astrophysics of Galaxies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to distinguish the Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) feedback models through the thermal Sunyaev - Zel’dovich effect (tSZ). Specifically, the researchers used the SIMBA cosmological galaxy formation simulation to evaluate the ability of tSZ measurements in revealing the influence of AGN feedback on the pressure structure of the circumgalactic medium (CGM). By calculating the total tSZ signal and its radial distribution under different AGN feedback assumptions and evaluating the consistency of these signals with the current and future telescope observations, the researchers aim to provide direct evidence for the AGN feedback mechanism.

### Background of the Paper

One of the main mysteries in modern extragalactic astronomy is the "cosmic downsizing" phenomenon from redshift \( z \approx 2 \) to the present day. During this period, the characteristic mass of star - forming galaxies has decreased by about ten times, and the characteristic luminosity of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) has decreased by about a thousand times. This phenomenon is contrary to the prediction of the hierarchical model, which believes that over time, the mass of galaxies and the mass of active black holes will continue to increase. To explain this downsizing phenomenon, scientists have proposed the AGN feedback mechanism, that is, AGN ejects energy and matter into the surrounding CGM, thereby suppressing gas accretion and reducing star formation.

Although modern galaxy evolution simulations all rely on some form of AGN feedback to reproduce the observational results, the specific details of this process are still unknown. Therefore, the researchers hope to indirectly verify the existence of AGN feedback by observing the gas affected by the feedback. The tSZ effect is an effective detection method, which can reflect the pressure structure of the CGM by measuring the energy increase of the CMB when it passes through the high - temperature and dense gas region.

### Research Methods

The researchers used the SIMBA simulation to generate tSZ signal maps and analyzed them through the following steps:

1. **Sample Selection**: Three different galaxy samples were selected, respectively from the simulation with AGN feedback (AGN), the simulation without AGN feedback (N - AGN), and a subset containing only quiescent galaxies (AGN - Q).
2. **tSZ Signal Calculation**: Calculate the tSZ - \( y \) signal according to the gas density and temperature fields and generate high - resolution maps.
3. **Convolution Processing**: Convolve the generated tSZ maps with telescope beams of different resolutions (such as ACT and TolTEC) to simulate the actual observation conditions.
4. **Data Comparison**: Compare the simulation results with the existing observational data, especially the data at redshifts \( z \approx 1 \) and \( z \approx 0.5 \).

### Main Findings

- **Redshift \( z \approx 1 \)**: The AGN - Q sample is highly consistent with the observational data, while the N - AGN sample is obviously inconsistent, indicating that the galaxies at this redshift do experience AGN feedback.
- **Redshift \( z \approx 0.5 \)**: The AGN sample has a poor fit with the observational data, while the N - AGN sample is more consistent. This may mean that the SIMBA simulation injects too much energy at this redshift, or the observational data itself lacks evidence of AGN feedback.

### Conclusions

Through the tSZ effect, the researchers can provide strong evidence for the AGN feedback mechanism and point out that the current simulations may overestimate the influence of AGN feedback at some redshifts. Future higher - resolution observations will further verify these conclusions and provide more clues for understanding the AGN feedback mechanism.