Matthew T. Scoggins,Zoltán Haiman
Abstract:Supermassive black holes (SMBHs) with masses of $\sim 10^9 {\rm M_\odot}$ within the first billion year of the universe challenge our conventional understanding of black hole formation and growth. One pathway to these SMBHs proposes that supermassive stars (SMSs) born in pristine atomic cooling haloes (ACHs) yield massive seed BHs evolving to these early SMBHs. This scenario leads to an overly massive BH galaxy (OMBG), in which the BH to stellar mass ratio is initially $M_{\rm bh}/M_* \geq 1$, well in excess of the typical values of $\sim 10^{-3}$ at low redshifts. Previously, we have investigated two massive seed BH candidates from the \texttt{Renaissance} simulation and found that they remain outliers on the $M_{\rm bh}-M_{*}$ relation until the OMBG merges with a much more massive halo at $z{=}8$. In this work, we use Monte-Carlo merger trees to investigate the evolution of the $M_{\rm bh}-M_{*}$ relation for $50,000$ protogalaxies hosting massive BH seeds, across $10,000$ trees that merge into a $10^{12} {\rm M_\odot}$ halo at $z{=}6$. We find that up to $60\%$ (depending on growth parameters) of these OMBGs remain strong outliers for several 100 Myr, down to redshifts detectable with {\it JWST} and with sensitive X-ray telescopes. This represents a way to diagnose the massive-seed formation pathway for early SMBHs. We expect to find ${\sim} 0.1{-}1$ of these objects per {\it JWST} NIRCam field per unit redshift at $z\gtrsim 6$. Recently detected SMBHs with masses of $\sim 10^7~{\rm M_\odot}$ and low inferred stellar-mass hosts may be examples of this population.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to explore one way of the formation of high - redshift supermassive black holes (SMBHs), that is, through the evolution of massive seed black holes (MSBHs). Specifically, the paper focuses on how these massive seed black holes are formed from the remnants of supermassive stars (SMSs) in the early universe (within about 1 billion years), and finally evolve into the supermassive black holes we observe today.
### Background and challenges
1. **Existence of early supermassive black holes**:
- Observations have found that in the early universe with redshift \( z \geq 6 \), there are multiple bright quasars with a mass of about \( 10^9 M_\odot \), which challenges our traditional understanding of black hole formation and growth.
- The traditional accretion process is difficult to explain how these black holes reach such a large mass in such a short time (about 1 billion years).
2. **Formation pathways**:
- **Light - seed model**: It is proposed that the remnant black holes of Population III stars grow rapidly at a super - Eddington rate, but this model requires an extremely high accretion rate and has a short time window.
- **Heavy - seed model**: It is proposed to rapidly form seed black holes of \( 10^4 - 10^6 M_\odot \) through various mechanisms and then grow at the Eddington - limited rate. These mechanisms include super - Eddington accretion, the collision and merger of stellar - mass black holes or stars in primordial star clusters, and direct - collapse black holes (Direct - Collapse Black Holes, DCBHs).
3. **Direct - collapse black holes (DCBHs)**:
- Chemically pure atomic - cooling halos (Atomic Cooling Haloes, ACHs) collapse to form supermassive stars (SMSs) through rapid hydrogen - atom cooling without previous star formation, and finally collapse into massive seed black holes.
- A key feature of this pathway is that the mass of the formed seed black hole is initially much larger than the stellar mass of its host galaxy, that is, \( M_{\text{bh}} / M_* \geq 1 \), which is in sharp contrast to the typical value of \( M_{\text{bh}} / M_* \sim 10^{-3} \) at low redshift.
### Research methods
1. **Monte Carlo merger trees**:
- Use the Monte Carlo method to generate the historical merger trees of dark matter halos, and simulate the merger history of \( 10^{12} M_\odot \) dark matter halos at redshift \( z = 6 \).
- Through these merger trees, identify the candidate locations where DCBHs may be formed, and track the evolution of their mass ratio \( M_{\text{bh}} / M_* \).
2. **Candidate DCBH selection**:
- By comparing the cooling time and the Hubble time, determine which halos have no star formation before reaching the atomic - cooling threshold (Atomic Cooling Threshold, ACT), and thus become DCBH candidates.
- Evaluate the number of DCBH candidates and their merger histories in different scenarios (the most optimistic and the most pessimistic).
3. **Mass - evolution model**:
- Assign stellar mass and black hole mass to each halo, and use different fitting formulas to describe the relationship between stellar mass and halo mass.
- Assume that the black hole starts to grow at the Eddington - limited rate immediately after formation, and consider the growth suppression when the black hole mass exceeds a certain proportion of the baryonic matter in the halo.
### Main conclusions
1. **Duration of excessive mass ratio**:
- It is found that up to 60% of the excessive mass ratios (OMBGs) remain significantly abnormal within hundreds of millions of years, and can still be detected by JWST and sensitive X - ray telescopes until redshift \( z \sim 8 \).
- It is expected that about 0.1 - 1 such objects can be found in each JWST NIRCam field per unit redshift \( z > 6 \)