Abstract:We report on progress in understanding how to construct color-dual multi-loop amplitudes. First we identify a cubic theory, semi-abelian Yang-Mills, that unifies many of the color-dual theories studied in the literature, and provides a prescriptive approach for constructing $D$-dimensional color-dual numerators through one-loop directly from Feynman rules. By a simple weight counting argument, this approach does not further generalize to two-loops. As a first step in understanding the two-loop challenge, we use a $D$-dimensional color-dual bootstrap to successfully construct globally color-dual local two-loop four-point nonlinear sigma model (NLSM) numerators. The double-copy of these NLSM numerators with themselves, pure Yang-Mills, and $\mathcal{N}=4$ super-Yang-Mills correctly reproduce the known unitarity constructed integrands of special Galileons, Born-Infeld theory, and Dirac-Born-Infeld-Volkov-Akulov theory, respectively. Applying our bootstrap to two-loop four-point pure Yang-Mills, we exhaustively search the space of local numerators and find that it fails to satisfy global color-kinematics duality, completing a search previously initiated in the literature. We pinpoint the failure to the bowtie unitarity cut, and discuss a path forward towards non-local construction of color-dual integrands at generic loop order.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to construct the color - dual representation in multi - loop integrals, especially to realize the global color - kinematics duality in the non - linear sigma model (NLSM) and Yang - Mills theory (YM) at two - loop and higher orders. Specifically, the paper explores how to construct the color - dual integral forms of these theories at the multi - loop level and whether these constructions can meet the requirements of color - kinematics duality globally. ### Core problems of the paper: 1. **Construction of color - dual representation**: The paper first identifies a cubic theory - semi - abelian Yang - Mills theory, which unifies the color - dual theories studied in many literatures and provides a method to directly construct one - loop color - dual numerators from D - dimensions through Feynman rules. However, this method encounters obstacles at the two - loop level. 2. **Challenges at the two - loop level**: In order to understand the challenges at the two - loop level, the paper successfully constructs the global color - dual local two - loop numerators of the four - point non - linear sigma model (NLSM) using the D - dimensional color - dual bootstrap method. Through double - copy verification, these NLSM numerators correctly reproduce the known unitarity - constructed integral expressions of the special Galileon, Born - Infeld theory and Dirac - Born - Infeld - Volkov - Akulov theory respectively when double - copied with themselves, pure Yang - Mills and N = 4 super - Yang - Mills. 3. **Limitations of Yang - Mills theory**: The paper further studies the case of two - loop four - point pure Yang - Mills and finds that it is impossible to construct globally color - dual local numerators. Specifically, the problem lies in the "bowtie" unitarity cut, which indicates that in two - loop and higher orders, the Yang - Mills theory may need to introduce non - local terms to achieve global color - duality. ### Main conclusions: - **Semi - abelian Yang - Mills theory**: At the one - loop level, the semi - abelian Yang - Mills theory can successfully construct D - dimensional color - dual numerators, but this method encounters obstacles at the two - loop level. - **Two - loop numerators of NLSM**: Through the D - dimensional color - dual bootstrap method, the two - loop four - point numerators of NLSM are successfully constructed, and these numerators perform well in double - copy verification. - **Failure of Yang - Mills theory**: At the two - loop level, the pure Yang - Mills theory cannot construct globally color - dual local numerators, and the main problem lies in the "bowtie" unitarity cut. ### Future directions: - **Non - local construction**: The paper discusses possible future research directions, including exploring the introduction of non - local terms to overcome the current obstacles encountered at two - loop and higher orders. In general, this paper has made important progress in the construction of color - dual representation at the multi - loop level, but it also points out the difficulties in realizing global color - duality in Yang - Mills theory and proposes possible solutions.

Revealing the Landscape of Globally Color-Dual Multi-loop Integrands

Revealing the landscape of globally color-dual multi-loop integrands

Virtual color-kinematics duality: 6-pt 1-loop MHV amplitudes

Applying Color-Kinematics Duality in Pure Yang-Mills at Three Loops

Color-kinematics dual representations of one-loop matrix elements in the open-superstring effective action

An exercise in Color-Dual Cut Tiling: $\mathcal{N}=8$ Supergravity from Positivity

Color-Kinematics Duality with Minimal Deformation: Two-Loop Four-Gluon Amplitudes in Pure Yang-Mills Revisited

Dual-color decompositions at one-loop level in Yang-Mills theory

Even-point Multi-loop Unitarity and its Applications: Exponentiation, Anomalies and Evanescence

Manifestly Dual-Conformal Loop Integration

Loop-level double-copy for massive fermions in the fundamental

Lagrangians Manifesting Color-Kinematics Duality in the NMHV Sector of Yang-Mills

The Color-Dual Fates of $F^3$, $R^3$, and $\mathcal{N}=4$ Supergravity

Two-loop $\mathcal{N}=1$ SYM Amplitudes via SUSY Decomposition and Massive Spinor-Helicity

Two-Loop Five-Point Two-Mass Planar Integrals and Double Lagrangian Insertions in a Wilson Loop

String Theory Duals of Wilson Loops from Higgsing

Loops of Loops Expansion in the Amplituhedron