Abstract:Surveys are an indispensable source of data for applied economic research; however, their reliance on self-reported information can introduce bias, especially if core variables such as personal income are misreported. To assess the extent and impact of this misreporting bias, we compare self-reported wages from the German Socio-Economic Panel (SOEP) with administrative wages from social security records (IEB) for the same individuals. Using a novel and unique data linkage (SOEP-ADIAB), we identify a modest but economically significant reporting bias, with SOEP respondents underreporting their administrative wages by about 7.3%. This misreporting varies systematically with individual, household, and especially job and firm characteristics. In replicating common empirical analyses in which wages serve as either dependent or independent variables, we find that misreporting is consequential for some, but not all estimated relationships. It turns out to be inconsequential for examining the returns to education, but relevant for analyzing the gender wage gap. In addition we find that misreporting bias can significantly affect the results when wage is used as the independent variable. Specifically, estimates of the wage-satisfaction relationship are substantially overestimated when based on survey data, although this bias is mitigated when focusing on interpersonal changes. Our findings underscore that survey-based measures of individual wages can significantly bias commonly estimated empirical relationships. They also demonstrate the enormous research potential of linked administrative-survey data.

The Accuracy of Job Seekers' Wage Expectations

Worker Beliefs About Outside Options

Subjective unemployment expectations and (self-)insurance

On the Extent, Correlates, and Consequences of Reporting Bias in Survey Wages

Modelling the process of job search

Self-regulation During Job Search: the Opposing Effects of Employment Self-Efficacy and Job Search Behavior Self-Efficacy.

Job Search with Financial Information: Theory and Evidence

In search of a job—But which one? How unemployed people revise their occupational expectations

Asymmetric Reciprocity and the Cyclical Behavior of Wages, Effort, and Job Creation

Locus of Control and Job Search Strategies

Gender Differences in Wage Expectations

Wages as signals of worker mobility

Earnings Expectation and Graduate Employment: Evidence from Recent Chinese College Graduates

Job Market Signaling

How much do workers search?

On the ambiguity of job search

Gender differences in wage expectations and negotiation

Network effects across the earnings distribution: payoffs to visible and invisible job finding assistance

An Empirical Analysis of Earnings and Employment Risk

Overprecision in the Survey of Professional Forecasters

Examining interindividual differences in unemployment-related changes in subjective well-being: The role of psychological well-being and re-employment expectations