Internal magnetic fields in 13 red giants detected by asteroseismology

Gang Li,Sébastien Deheuvels,Tanda Li,Jérôme Ballot,François Lignières
2023-09-25
Abstract:While surface fields have been measured for stars across the HR diagram, internal magnetic fields remain largely unknown. The recent seismic detection of magnetic fields in the cores of several Kepler red giants has opened a new avenue to understand better the origin of magnetic fields and their impact on stellar structure and evolution. We aim to use asteroseismology to systematically search for internal magnetic fields in red giant stars and to determine the strengths and geometries of these fields. Magnetic fields are known to break the symmetry of rotational multiplets. In red giants, oscillation modes are mixed, behaving as pressure modes in the envelope and as gravity modes in the core. Magnetism-induced asymmetries are expected to be stronger for g-dominated modes than for p-dominated modes and to decrease with frequency. After collecting a sample of 2500 Kepler red giant stars with clear mixed-mode patterns, we specifically searched for targets among 1200 stars with dipole triplets. We identified 13 stars exhibiting clear asymmetric multiplets and measured their parameters, especially the asymmetry parameter and the magnetic frequency shift. By combining these estimates with best-fitting stellar models, we measured average core magnetic fields ranging from 20 to 150kG, corresponding to 5% to 30% of the critical field strengths. We showed that the detected core fields have various horizontal geometries, some of which significantly differ from a dipolar configuration. We found that the field strengths decrease with stellar evolution, despite the fact that the cores of these stars are contracting. Even though these stars have strong internal magnetic fields, they display normal core rotation rates, suggesting no significantly different histories of angular momentum transport compared to other red giant stars. We also discuss the possible origin of the detected fields.
Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to systematically search for internal magnetic fields in red giants observed by the Kepler satellite using asteroseismology methods, and to determine the strength and geometric structure of these magnetic fields. Specifically, the research aims to detect magnetic fields within the cores of red giants. These magnetic fields have an impact on the structure and evolution of stars, but currently very little is known about them. By analyzing the oscillation modes of red giants, especially the asymmetry of mixed modes, researchers hope to reveal the existence and characteristics of these internal magnetic fields. ### Research Background and Objectives **Background**: - **Influence of Magnetic Fields**: Magnetic fields play an important role in all evolutionary stages of stars, especially in terms of angular momentum transfer. Although surface magnetic fields have been measured by various methods, internal magnetic fields remain an unsolved mystery. - **Application of Asteroseismology**: In recent years, magnetic fields have been detected in the cores of several Kepler red giants through asteroseismology methods, which has opened up new avenues for understanding the origin of magnetic fields and their impact on the structure and evolution of stars. **Objectives**: - **Systematic Search**: Systematically search for internal magnetic fields in red giants observed by the Kepler satellite using asteroseismology methods. - **Parameter Determination**: Determine the strength and geometric structure of these magnetic fields. ### Methods **Methods**: - **Magnetic Field Effects**: Magnetic fields break the symmetry of rotational multiplets. In red giants, oscillation modes are mixed, behaving as pressure modes in the envelope and gravity modes in the core. The asymmetry caused by magnetic fields is stronger in gravity - dominated modes than in pressure - dominated modes and weakens as the frequency increases. - **Data Processing**: From about 2,500 Kepler red giants with clear mixed modes, about 1,200 stars with dipole triplets are screened out to further search for asymmetries that satisfy the above properties. ### Results **Results**: - **Detected Stars**: Among the screened samples, 13 stars showing obvious asymmetric multiplets are identified, and their parameters, especially the asymmetry parameter \(a\) and magnetic frequency shift \(\delta\nu_g\), are measured. - **Magnetic Field Strength**: Combining the best - fitting stellar models, the average core magnetic field strength is measured, ranging from about 20 kG to about 150 kG, equivalent to 5% to 30% of the critical field strength. - **Magnetic Field Geometry**: The detected core magnetic fields have different horizontal geometric structures, some of which are significantly different from the dipole configuration. - **Evolutionary Trend**: Although the cores of these stars are contracting, the magnetic field strength decreases with the evolution of the stars. Moreover, even though these stars have strong internal magnetic fields, their core rotation rates are still normal, indicating that their angular momentum transfer history is not significantly different from that of other red giants. ### Discussion **Discussion**: - **Origin of Magnetic Fields**: The research results provide important clues to the origin and evolution of internal magnetic fields, especially their impact on angular momentum transfer. - **Observation Bias**: The research method has a certain observation bias. For example, for very strong magnetic fields, their regular influence on the period spacing is large, which may lead to difficulties in detecting these strong magnetic fields. ### Conclusions **Conclusions**: - **Main Findings**: Through systematic search, the research team has detected obvious internal magnetic fields in 13 red giants. These magnetic fields have different geometric structures and strengths. - **Future Work**: Future work will further explore the seismological characteristics of non - axisymmetric magnetic fields and the prevalence of these magnetic fields in other types of stars. ### Formulas - **Asymmetry Parameter \(a\)**: \[ a=\frac{\int_{r_i}^{r_o}K(r)B_r^2P_2(\cos\theta)\sin\theta \, d\theta \, d\phi \, dr}{\int_{r_i}^{r_o}K(r)B_r^2\sin\theta \, d\theta \, d\phi \, dr} \] where \(- 0.5 < a < 1\), and the specific value depends on the latitudinal distribution of \(B_r^2\) in the oscillation cavity. - **Period of Pure g - mode**: \[ P'_{g,m}=