Performance Analysis of UNet and Variants for Medical Image Segmentation

Walid Ehab,Yongmin Li
2023-09-23
Abstract:Medical imaging plays a crucial role in modern healthcare by providing non-invasive visualisation of internal structures and abnormalities, enabling early disease detection, accurate diagnosis, and treatment planning. This study aims to explore the application of deep learning models, particularly focusing on the UNet architecture and its variants, in medical image segmentation. We seek to evaluate the performance of these models across various challenging medical image segmentation tasks, addressing issues such as image normalization, resizing, architecture choices, loss function design, and hyperparameter tuning. The findings reveal that the standard UNet, when extended with a deep network layer, is a proficient medical image segmentation model, while the Res-UNet and Attention Res-UNet architectures demonstrate smoother convergence and superior performance, particularly when handling fine image details. The study also addresses the challenge of high class imbalance through careful preprocessing and loss function definitions. We anticipate that the results of this study will provide useful insights for researchers seeking to apply these models to new medical imaging problems and offer guidance and best practices for their implementation.
Image and Video Processing,Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the application of deep - learning models, especially the UNet architecture and its variants (Res - UNet and Attention Res - UNet), in medical image segmentation. Specifically, the paper attempts to solve the following key problems: 1. **Improve the accuracy of medical image segmentation**: - By evaluating the performance of different deep - learning models in medical image segmentation tasks, the paper explores how to improve the accuracy of segmentation. This includes dealing with complex medical image features, such as the fine - grained segmentation of structures such as organs, tumors, and blood vessels. 2. **Address the challenges in medical image segmentation**: - Medical image segmentation faces many challenges, such as image normalization, scaling, architecture selection, loss function design, and hyper - parameter tuning. The paper verifies the effectiveness of these models in dealing with these problems through experiments. - In particular, in response to the problem of high - class imbalance, the paper addresses this challenge through careful pre - processing and loss function definition. 3. **Evaluate the performance of different models**: - The paper conducts a detailed performance evaluation of the standard UNet, Res - UNet, and Attention Res - UNet. The results show that the standard UNet performs well after expanding the deep network layers, while Res - UNet and Attention Res - UNet have smoother convergence and higher performance in dealing with detailed images. 4. **Provide best practices and guidance**: - The paper hopes to provide useful insights for researchers through its research results, help them apply these models in new medical imaging problems, and provide guidance and best practices for model implementation. ### Formula presentation To ensure the correctness and readability of the formulas, the following are some important formulas involved in the paper: - **Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC)**: \[ DSC=\frac{2\times|A\cap B|}{|A| + |B|} \] where: - \(A\) is the predicted segmentation mask; - \(B\) is the real - reference mask; - \(|\cdot|\) represents the cardinality of a set, that is, the number of elements in the set; - \(\cap\) represents the intersection operation. - **Binary Focal Loss (BFL)**: \[ BFL =-(1 - p_t)^\gamma\cdot\log(p_t) \] where: - \(p_t\) represents the probability of the predicted true class label; - \(\gamma\) is an adjustable hyper - parameter, called the focusing parameter; - \(\log(\cdot)\) is the natural logarithm. Through these formulas, the paper evaluates in detail the performance of different models in medical image segmentation tasks and proposes improved methods and suggestions.