Comparative study of some rigorous and approximate methods for calculating the energy loss straggling
P.B. Kats,A.V. Kudravets,A.S. Rimashevskaya,О.O. Voskresenskaya
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.radphyschem.2024.111860
IF: 2.776
2024-05-30
Radiation Physics and Chemistry
Abstract:Some exact and approximate methods commonly used to calculate corrections to the Bethe stopping formula are modified and adapted by the authors to the calculation of the energy loss straggling (ELS). An intercomparison is carried out for results of approaches developed in the present work. An excellent agreement obtained between the results for ELS, calculated with an exact method previously proposed by one of the authors and the results of the Lindhard–Sørensen method for moderate relativistic energies. It is shown that some modified by authors approximate methods for the ELS calculating have the higher accuracy than the conventional approximate method of Lijian−Qing−Zhengming (LQZ). So, in all the cases considered, the accuracy of the twice modified LQZ method in the ELS calculations is higher than the accuracy of the usual LQZ method. The velocity averages of the relative error for Z = 92–118 of LQZ varies from 0.08% to 0.33%, and of LQZ m2 – from 0.03% to 0.09%. A thrice modified LQZ method was also suggested in this work. The average error of LQZ m3 becomes lower than the average error of LQZ, starting from Z = 99, and lower than the error of LQZ m2 , starting from Z = 109. A number of shortened LQZ methods for the ELS calculating have been proposed and developed too.
chemistry, physical,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical,nuclear science & technology