A knowledge representation approach for construction contract knowledge modeling

Chunmo Zheng,Saika Wong,Xing Su,Yinqiu Tang

2023-09-21

Abstract:The emergence of large language models (LLMs) presents an unprecedented opportunity to automate construction contract management, reducing human errors and saving significant time and costs. However, LLMs may produce convincing yet inaccurate and misleading content due to a lack of domain expertise. To address this issue, expert-driven contract knowledge can be represented in a structured manner to constrain the automatic contract management process. This paper introduces the Nested Contract Knowledge Graph (NCKG), a knowledge representation approach that captures the complexity of contract knowledge using a nested structure. It includes a nested knowledge representation framework, a NCKG ontology built on the framework, and an implementation method. Furthermore, we present the LLM-assisted contract review pipeline enhanced with external knowledge in NCKG. Our pipeline achieves a promising performance in contract risk reviewing, shedding light on the combination of LLM and KG towards more reliable and interpretable contract management.

Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in construction contract management, although natural language processing (NLP) technology can significantly improve efficiency, large - language models (LLMs) may generate wrong or misleading content due to the lack of domain - specific knowledge. To solve this problem, the paper proposes a new knowledge representation method - Nested Contract Knowledge Graph (NCKG), which represents expert - driven contract knowledge in a structured way, thereby constraining the automatic contract management process, reducing human errors and saving time and cost.

Specifically, the paper mainly focuses on the following points:

1. **Semantic ambiguity and complexity in contract texts**:
- Construction contracts are usually written in natural language, which is prone to semantic fuzziness and ambiguity, leading to misunderstandings and conflicts among parties.
- It is difficult to accurately assess the risks in contract terms, which may lead to potential problems.

2. **Limitations of current contract management methods**:
- Current methods still rely on manual processing and human expertise, which are both time - consuming and error - prone.
- An automated method is needed to assist contract management, especially in the bidding and signing stages.

3. **Challenges of large - language models (LLMs)**:
- LLMs perform well in handling general language tasks, but they are insufficient in language and logical reasoning in specific domains (such as construction contracts).
- LLMs may generate inaccurate or misleading content because they lack domain - specific knowledge.

4. **Solutions**:
- Propose NCKG as a knowledge representation method to capture the complexity of contract knowledge through a nested structure.
- Include a nested knowledge representation framework, the NCKG ontology constructed based on this framework, and implementation methods.
- Combine external knowledge to enhance the LLM - assisted contract review process and improve the accuracy of contract risk review.

Through these measures, the paper aims to combine the advantages of LLM and KG to provide a more reliable and interpretable contract management method.