Abstract:The recent claim of room temperature superconductivity in a copper-doped lead apatite compound, called LK-99, has sparked remarkable interest and controversy. Subsequent experiments have largely failed to reproduce the claimed superconductivity, while theoretical works have identified multiple key features including strong electronic correlation, structural instabilities, and dopability constraints. A puzzling claim of several recent theoretical studies is that both parent and copper-doped lead apatite structures are dynamically unstable at the harmonic level, questioning decades of experimental reports of the parent compound structures and the recently proposed copper-doped structures. In this work, we demonstrate that both parent and copper-doped lead apatite structures are dynamically stable at room temperature. Anharmonic phonon-phonon interactions play a key role in stabilizing some copper-doped phases, while most phases are largely stable even at the harmonic level. We also show that dynamical stability depends on both volume and correlation strength, suggesting controllable ways of exploring the copper-doped lead apatite structural phase diagram. Our results fully reconcile the theoretical description of the structures of both parent and copper-doped lead apatite with experiment.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper mainly attempts to solve the controversies and theoretical inconsistencies regarding the superconductivity of copper - doped apatite (LK - 99) at room temperature. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following key issues: 1. **Controversies over the superconductivity of LK - 99**: - Recently, some studies have claimed that copper - doped apatite (LK - 99) exhibits superconductivity at room temperature and normal pressure, but subsequent experiments have failed to replicate this result. Theoretically, some studies have shown that this material is kinetically unstable at the harmonic level, which contradicts decades of experimental reports. 2. **Structural stability issues**: - The paper explores the kinetic stability of the parent apatites (Pb₁₀(PO₄)₆O and Pb₁₀(PO₄)₆(OH)₂) and copper - doped apatite (Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O). Previous studies have shown that these structures are unstable at the harmonic level, which has raised questions about the actual stability of these materials. 3. **Explaining the differences between experiments and theory**: - The authors aim to explain why these materials are actually kinetically stable at room temperature by introducing anharmonic effects and verify whether these structures can represent real materials. 4. **Exploring factors affecting structural stability**: - The research also explores the effects of volume and electron correlation strength (such as the Hubbard U parameter) on the structural stability of copper - doped apatite, and proposes the possibility of exploring its structural phase diagram by controlling these parameters. ### Main conclusions The main conclusions of the paper include: - **Stability of the parent apatites**: Pb₁₀(PO₄)₆O and Pb₁₀(PO₄)₆(OH)₂ are basically stable at the harmonic level. Although there are slight instabilities in some cases, these instabilities can be suppressed by quartic anharmonic effects. - **Stability of copper - doped apatite**: For copper - doped apatite, some structures are unstable at the harmonic level, but after introducing anharmonic effects, these structures are stable at room temperature. In particular, for Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O, when the copper atom is located at the Pb(2) site, the structure is stable at the harmonic level; when the copper atom is located at the Pb(1) site, although it is unstable at the harmonic level, it becomes stable at room temperature through anharmonic effects. - **Regulation of the structural phase diagram**: By adjusting the volume and electron correlation strength, the structural phase diagram of copper - doped apatite can be regulated, and thus temperature - driven structural phase transitions may be observed. Through these studies, the authors have resolved the theoretical controversies regarding the structural stability of LK - 99 and provided a new perspective for future experimental and theoretical research.

On the dynamical stability of copper-doped lead apatite

Phase Stability of Lead Phosphate Apatite Pb$_{10-x}$Cu$_{x}$(PO$_{4}$)$_{6}$O, Pb$_{10-x}$Cu$_{x}$(PO$_{4}$)$_{6}$(OH)$_{2}$, and Pb$_{8}$Cu$_{2}$(PO$_{4}$)$_{6}$

Phase Stability of Lead Phosphate Apatite Pb 10– x Cu x (PO 4 ) 6 O, Pb 10– x Cu x (PO 4 ) 6 (OH) 2 ( x = 0, 1), and Pb 8 Cu 2 (PO 4 ) 6

Electronic Structure and Vibrational Stability of Copper-substituted Lead Apatite (LK-99)

Unveiling the Impact of Sulfur Doping on Copper-Substituted Lead Apatite: A Theoretical Study

Structural and Electronic Intricacies of Cu-Doped Lead Apatite (LK-99): Implications for Potential Ambient-Pressure Superconductivity

Deciphering the Enigma of Cu-Doped Lead Apatite (LK-99): Structural Insights, Electronic Properties, and Implications for Ambient-Pressure Superconductivity

Ab initio Investigations on the Electronic Properties and Stability of Cu-Substituted Lead Apatite (LK-99) family with different doping concentrations (x=0, 1, 2)

Metallization and spin fluctuations in Cu-doped lead apatite

Observation of diamagnetic strange-metal phase in sulfur-copper codoped lead apatite

First-principles calculation on the electronic structures, phonon dynamics, and electrical conductivities of Pb$_{10}$(PO$_4$)$_6$O and Pb$_9$Cu(PO$_4$)$_6$O compounds

The 1/4 occupied O atoms induced ultraflat band and the one dimensional channels in the Pb$_{10-x}$Cu$_{x}$(PO$_4$)$_{6}$O$_{4}$ (x=0,0.5) crystal

Exceptional metal-semiconductor-metal transition of lead apatites via oxygen defect tuning

Current percolation model for the special resistivity behavior observed in Cu-doped Apatite

Pb$_9$Cu(PO4)$_6$(OH)$_2$: Phonon bands, Localized Flat Band Magnetism, Models, and Chemical Analysis

Structure and lattice excitations of the copper substituted lead oxyapatite Pb$_{9.06(7)}$Cu$_{0.94(6)}$(PO$_{3.92(4)}$)$_{6}$O$_{0.96(3)}$

Electron-phonon coupling in copper-substituted lead phosphate apatite

Effective tight-binding Hamiltonian for the low-energy electronic structure of the Cu-doped lead apatite and the parent compound

Symmetry breaking induced insulating electronic state in Pb$_{9}$Cu(PO$_4$)$_6$O

Edge-sharing quasi-one-dimensional cuprate fragments in optimally substituted Cu/Pb apatite