Turán Colourings in Off-Diagonal Ramsey Multiplicity

Joseph Hyde,Jae-baek Lee,Jonathan A. Noel

2024-01-30

Abstract:The \emph{Ramsey multiplicity constant} of a graph $H$ is the limit as $n$ tends to infinity of the minimum density of monochromatic labeled copies of $H$ in a $2$-edge colouring of $K_n$. Fox and Wigderson recently identified a large family of graphs whose Ramsey multiplicity constants are attained by sequences of ``Turán colourings''; i.e. colourings in which one of the colour classes forms the edge set of a balanced complete multipartite graph. Each graph in their family comes from taking a connected non-3-colourable graph with a critical edge and adding many pendant edges. We extend their result to an off-diagonal variant of the Ramsey multiplicity constant which involves minimizing a weighted sum of red copies of one graph and blue copies of another.

Combinatorics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is a variant of the Ramsey multiplicity problem in discrete mathematics. Specifically, the authors studied how to minimize the weighted sum of the number of red copies of a specific graph \(H_1\) and the number of blue copies of another graph \(H_2\) when the edges of the complete graph \(K_n\) are colored red - blue. This problem can be regarded as a non - diagonal generalization of the traditional Ramsey multiplicity problem, where the goal is to minimize a linear combination rather than the number of monochromatic copies of a single graph.

### Background knowledge
- **Ramsey multiplicity**: For a given graph \(H\), the Ramsey multiplicity constant refers to the minimum monochromatic marked \(H\) copy density when the edges of \(K_n\) are colored red - blue as \(n\) approaches infinity.
- **Turán coloring**: A special coloring method in which one color class forms the edge set of a balanced complete multi - part graph.
- **Non - diagonal Ramsey multiplicity**: Consider two different graphs \(H_1\) and \(H_2\), and the goal is to minimize the weighted sum of red \(H_1\) copies and blue \(H_2\) copies.

### Main contributions of the paper
- **Extending known results**: The paper extends the results of Fox and Wigderson, who proved that the Ramsey multiplicity constant of a class of graphs can be achieved by Turán coloring. This paper generalizes it to the non - diagonal setting.
- **Defining "bonbon pairs"**: If for a sufficiently large \(n\), the only coloring method that minimizes the weighted sum is Turán coloring, then \((H_1, H_2)\) is called a bonbon pair.
- **Main theorem**: For graphs \(F_1\) and \(F_2\) that satisfy certain conditions, there exists a \(t_0\) such that when \(H_1\) and \(H_2\) are \(t_1\)-hairy \(F_1\) and \(t_2\)-hairy \(F_2\) respectively and \(t_1, t_2\geq t_0\), \((H_1, H_2)\) is a bonbon pair.

### Specific problems
- **Problem description**: How to minimize the weighted sum of red \(H_1\) copies and blue \(H_2\) copies when the edges of the complete graph \(K_n\) are colored red - blue?
- **Solution**: Minimize this weighted sum through the Turán coloring method, that is, one color class forms the edge set of a balanced complete multi - part graph.

### Mathematical formulas
- **Ramsey multiplicity constant**:
\[
c_\lambda(H_1, H_2):=\lim_{n\rightarrow\infty}\left[\min_{G:v(G) = n}\left(\lambda\cdot t(H_1, G)+(2 - \lambda)\cdot t(H_2, G)\right)\right]
\]
- **Injection homomorphism density**:
\[
t_{\text{inj}}(H, G)=\frac{\text{The number of homomorphisms from }V(H)\text{ to }V(G)}{|V(G)|^{|V(H)|}}
\]

### Conclusion
This paper extends the existing theoretical framework by introducing the concept of bonbon pairs and proving that under specific conditions, the non - diagonal Ramsey multiplicity problem can be solved by the Turán coloring method. This result provides a new perspective for understanding the coloring problems of complex graphs.