Unveiling the Complexity of Neural Populations: Evaluating the Validity and Limitations of the Wilson-Cowan Model

Maryam Saadati,Saba Sadat Khodaei,Yousef Jamali

2023-09-12

Abstract:The population model of Wilson-Cowan is perhaps the most popular in the history of computational neuroscience. It embraces the nonlinear mean field dynamics of excitatory and inhibitory neuronal populations provided via a temporal coarse-graining technique. The traditional Wilson-Cowan equations exhibit either steady-state regimes or else limit cycle competitions for an appropriate range of parameters. As these equations lower the resolution of the neural system and obscure vital information, we assess the validity of mass-type model approximations for complex neural behaviors. Using a large-scale network of Hodgkin-Huxley style neurons, we derive implicit average population dynamics based on mean field assumptions. Our comparison of the microscopic neural activity with the macroscopic temporal profiles reveals dependency on the binary state of interacting subpopulations and the random property of the structural network at the Hopf bifurcation points when different synaptic weights are considered. For substantial configurations of stimulus intensity, our model provides further estimates of the neural population's dynamics official, ranging from simple periodic to quasi-periodic and aperiodic patterns, as well as phase transition regimes. While this shows its great potential for studying the collective behavior of individual neurons particularly concentrating on the occurrence of bifurcation phenomena, we must accept a quite limited accuracy of the Wilson-Cowan approximations-at least in some parameter regimes. Additionally, we report that the complexity and temporal diversity of neural dynamics, especially in terms of limit cycle trajectory, and synchronization can be induced by either small heterogeneity in the degree of various types of local excitatory connectivity or considerable diversity in the external drive to the excitatory pool.

Neurons and Cognition,Chaotic Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper mainly discusses the effectiveness and limitations of the Wilson-Cowan model in neural population models. The Wilson-Cowan model is a widely used computational neuroscience model that simplifies the nonlinear dynamics of excitatory (E) and inhibitory (I) neural populations. The study analyzes the dynamic behavior of neural networks at the microscopic level by combining the Hodgkin-Huxley model (considering biophysical details) and the Wilson-Cowan model (considering mean-field approximation).

Under different parameters, the study found that the Wilson-Cowan model can generate different types of dynamic patterns, but may not fully capture the complexity of real neural systems. When synaptic connection weights are close to the critical point, the dynamic properties of the model depend on the bimodal nature of neurons (transition between active and inactive states) and the randomness of the network structure. In addition, the model reveals how the diversity of external stimulus intensity and local excitatory connectivity influences the dynamic behavior of neurons, such as periodic, quasi-periodic, and aperiodic patterns, as well as phase transitions.

The study also points out that compared to the Wilson-Cowan model, the microscopic neural network exhibits unpredictable complex dynamic landscapes under certain conditions, mainly due to the neglect of stochastic effects in the model. These findings emphasize the limitations of relying solely on macroscopic neural mass models to understand the intrinsic complexity of the nervous system, and indicate the need for more detailed models to capture the full range of dynamic behaviors of neural populations.