Supernovae Ia and Gamma-Ray Bursts together shed new lights on the Hubble constant tension and cosmology

M. G. Dainotti,B. De Simone,G. Montani,E. Rinaldi,M. Bogdan,K. M. Islam,A. Gangopadhyay

2023-09-12

Abstract:The LambdaCDM model is the most commonly accepted framework in modern cosmology. However, the local measurements of the Hubble constant, H0, via the Supernovae Type Ia (SNe Ia) calibrated on Cepheids provide a value which is in significant disagreement, from 4 to 6 sigma, with the value of H0 inferred from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) observed by Planck. This disagreement is the so-called Hubble constant tension. To find out the reason for this discrepancy, we analyze the behaviour of the H0 in the Pantheon sample of SNe Ia through a binning approach: we divide the Pantheon into 3 and 4 bins ordered with redshift (z), and for each of them, we estimate the H0. After the H0 estimation, we fit the H0 values with a decreasing function of z, finding out that H0 undergoes a slow decreasing trend compatible with the evolution scenario in 2.0 sigma. [...] Together with SNe Ia, more astrophysical probes such as quasars (QSO) [...] and Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) [...], are needed to tackle the H0 tension. In the realm of GRB-cosmology, one of the most promising correlations is the fundamental plane relation [...]. In the context of applying this relation as a cosmological tool, we also compute how many GRBs must be gathered to reach the same precision as the SNe Ia. Since we are about two decades away from reaching such precision, we also attempt to find additional correlations for the GRBs associated with SNe Ibc that could be exploited to standardize the class of GRB-SNe Ibc in the future. We find a hint of a correlation between the GRBs' end-of-plateau optical luminosity and the SNe's rest-frame peak time, suggesting that the GRBs with the most luminous optical plateau emission are associated with SNe with the most delayed peaks in their light curves. So far, it is the fundamental plane relation to be the most promising candle for exploring the high-z universe.

Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the **Hubble constant tension**. Specifically, the paper explores alleviating or explaining this tension through data from Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and gamma - ray bursts (GRBs).

### Background
In modern cosmology, the ΛCDM model is the most widely - accepted standard cosmological model. However, there is a significant difference between the local Hubble constant \( H_0 \) value measured by Cepheid variables calibrated by Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and the \( H_0 \) value derived from the cosmic microwave background (CMB) observed by the Planck satellite. This difference is usually in the range of 4 - 6σ. This difference is called the **Hubble constant tension**.

### Research Methods
To explore the reasons for this tension, the paper adopts the following methods:

1. **SNe Ia Data Analysis**:
- Use 1,048 Type Ia supernovae data in the Pantheon sample.
- Divide the sample into 3 or 4 redshift (\( z \)) intervals and estimate \( H_0 \) within each interval.
- By fitting the trend of \( H_0 \) with redshift, it is found that \( H_0 \) slowly decreases with \( z \), and this trend is compatible with zero at the 2.0σ level.

2. **GRBs Data Analysis**:
- Explore the possibility of GRBs as high - redshift standard candles.
- Analyze the fundamental plane relation of GRBs, which involves the X - ray luminosity, duration, and peak luminosity of GRBs.
- By simulating 3,300 GRBs, evaluate the number required to achieve the same accuracy as SNe Ia using GRBs.

3. **New Correlation Exploration**:
- Search for new correlations in GRB - SNe events, especially the relationship between the optical plateau luminosity of GRBs and the rest - frame peak time of SNe.
- A possible correlation is discovered, that is, the more delayed the peak of SNe is, the higher the optical plateau luminosity of GRBs is.

### Main Conclusions
- **SNe Ia Analysis**: In the Pantheon sample, the trend that \( H_0 \) slowly decreases with redshift may be due to unknown astrophysical biases or the redshift evolution effect of SNe Ia parameters, or it is necessary to introduce modified gravity theories (such as \( f(R) \) gravity theory) to explain.
- **GRBs Analysis**: The fundamental plane relation of GRBs is one of the most promising high - redshift standard candle candidates at present. Through machine learning and light - curve reconstruction techniques, it is expected to achieve the same accuracy as SNe Ia by 2032.
- **New Correlation**: A correlation between the optical plateau luminosity of GRBs and the rest - frame peak time of SNe is preliminarily discovered, but more data are needed to confirm this result.

In conclusion, through multi - aspect data analysis and theoretical exploration, this paper aims to provide new insights and tools for solving the Hubble constant tension.