Abstract:BackgroundStriking a balance between the degree of model complexity and parameter identifiability, while still producing biologically feasible simulations using modelling is a major challenge in computational biology. While these two elements of model development are closely coupled, parameter fitting from measured data and analysis of model mechanisms have traditionally been performed separately and sequentially. This process produces potential mismatches between model and data complexities that can compromise the ability of computational frameworks to reveal mechanistic insights or predict new behaviour. In this study we address this issue by presenting a generic framework for combined model parameterisation, comparison of model alternatives and analysis of model mechanisms.ResultsThe presented methodology is based on a combination of multivariate metamodelling (statistical approximation of the input–output relationships of deterministic models) and a systematic zooming into biologically feasible regions of the parameter space by iterative generation of new experimental designs and look-up of simulations in the proximity of the measured data. The parameter fitting pipeline includes an implicit sensitivity analysis and analysis of parameter identifiability, making it suitable for testing hypotheses for model reduction. Using this approach, under-constrained model parameters, as well as the coupling between parameters within the model are identified. The methodology is demonstrated by refitting the parameters of a published model of cardiac cellular mechanics using a combination of measured data and synthetic data from an alternative model of the same system. Using this approach, reduced models with simplified expressions for the tropomyosin/crossbridge kinetics were found by identification of model components that can be omitted without affecting the fit to the parameterising data. Our analysis revealed that model parameters could be constrained to a standard deviation of on average 15% of the mean values over the succeeding parameter sets.ConclusionsOur results indicate that the presented approach is effective for comparing model alternatives and reducing models to the minimum complexity replicating measured data. We therefore believe that this approach has significant potential for reparameterising existing frameworks, for identification of redundant model components of large biophysical models and to increase their predictive capacity.

Parameter identifiability and model selection for partial differential equation models of cell invasion

Modeling of 2D Diffusion Processes Based on Microscopy Data: Parameter Estimation and Practical Identifiability Analysis

Robust parameter estimation and identifiability analysis with Hybrid Neural Ordinary Differential Equations in Computational Biology

Efficient inference and identifiability analysis for differential equation models with random parameters

Using Experimental Data and Information Criteria to Guide Model Selection for Reaction–Diffusion Problems in Mathematical Biology

Parameter identifiability in PDE models of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching

Delineating Parameter Unidentifiabilities in Complex Models

Identifiability of heterogeneous phenotype adaptation from low-cell-count experiments and a stochastic model

Likelihood-based inference, identifiability and prediction using count data from lattice-based random walk models

Navigating the landscape of parameter identifiability methods: A workflow recommendation for model development

Uncertainty Analysis for Non-identifiable Dynamical Systems: Profile Likelihoods, Bootstrapping and More

Algebraic identifiability of partial differential equation models

High-dimensional Bayesian Parameter Estimation: Case Study for a Model of JAK2/STAT5 Signaling.

Designing experimental conditions to use the Lotka-Volterra model to infer tumor cell line interaction types

Identifiability Implies Robust, Globally Exponentially Convergent On-line Parameter Estimation: Application to Model Reference Adaptive Control

Inference for Stochastic Chemical Kinetics Using Moment Equations and System Size Expansion

Parameter identifiability and redundancy: theoretical considerations

Insight into model mechanisms through automatic parameter fitting: a new methodological framework for model development

Parameter Estimation for Dynamical Systems with Discrete Events and Logical Operations

System identifiability in a time-evolving agent-based model