Abstract:Computational thinking in physics has many different forms, definitions, and implementations depending on the level of physics, or the institution it is presented in. In order to better integrate computational thinking in introductory physics, we need to understand what physicists find important about computational thinking in introductory physics. We present a qualitative analysis of twenty-six interviews asking academic (N=18) and industrial (N=8) physicists about the teaching and learning of computational thinking in introductory physics courses. These interviews are part of a longer-term project towards developing an assessment protocol for computational thinking in introductory physics. We find that academic and industrial physicists value students' ability to read code and that Python (or VPython) and spreadsheets were the preferred computational language or environment used. Additionally, the interviewees mentioned that identifying the core physics concepts within a program, explaining code to others, and good program hygiene (i.e., commenting and using meaningful variable names) are important skills for introductory students to acquire. We also find that while a handful of interviewees note that the experience and skills gained from computation are quite useful for student's future careers, they also describe multiple limiting factors of teaching computation in introductory physics, such as curricular overhaul, not having "space" for computation, and student rejection. The interviews show that while adding computational thinking to physics students repertoire is important, the importance really comes from using computational thinking to learn and understand physics better. This informs us that the assessment we develop should only include the basics of computational thinking needed to assess introductory physics knowledge.

How do we assess computation in physics?

Towards a Generalized Assessment of Computational Thinking for Introductory Physics Students

Students' perspectives on computational challenges in physics class

On the Prevalence and Nature of Computational Instruction in Undergraduate Physics Programs across the United States

Developing a learning goal framework for computational thinking in computationally integrated physics classrooms

Computational Essays in the Physics Classroom

How Physics Students Develop Disciplinary Computational Literacy

Understanding Student Computational Thinking with Computational Modeling

Physics computational literacy: An exploratory case study using computational essays

Student Representations of Computation in the Physics Community

A Case Study: Novel Group Interactions through Introductory Computational Physics

Computational Essays: An Avenue for Scientific Creativity in Physics

Computational Thinking in Introductory Physics

Assessing Students' Computational Thinking In A Learning By Modeling Environment

Fostering Computational Thinking

Implementing and assessing computational modeling in introductory mechanics

Computation in classical mechanics

Transforming High School Physics with Modeling and Computation

Physicality, Modeling and Making in a Computational Physics Class

Assessing computational thinking: A systematic review of empirical studies

The difficulties associated with integrating computation into undergraduate physics