Vector Autoregression in Cryptocurrency Markets: Unraveling Complex Causal Networks

Cameron Cornell,Lewis Mitchell,Matthew Roughan

2023-08-30

Abstract:Methodologies to infer financial networks from the price series of speculative assets vary, however, they generally involve bivariate or multivariate predictive modelling to reveal causal and correlational structures within the time series data. The required model complexity intimately relates to the underlying market efficiency, where one expects a highly developed and efficient market to display very few simple relationships in price data. This has spurred research into the applications of complex nonlinear models for developed markets. However, it remains unclear if simple models can provide meaningful and insightful descriptions of the dependency and interconnectedness of the rapidly developed cryptocurrency market. Here we show that multivariate linear models can create informative cryptocurrency networks that reflect economic intuition, and demonstrate the importance of high-influence nodes. The resulting network confirms that node degree, a measure of influence, is significantly correlated to the market capitalisation of each coin ($\rho=0.193$). However, there remains a proportion of nodes whose influence extends beyond what their market capitalisation would imply. We demonstrate that simple linear model structure reveals an inherent complexity associated with the interconnected nature of the data, supporting the use of multivariate modelling to prevent surrogate effects and achieve accurate causal representation. In a reductive experiment we show that most of the network structure is contained within a small portion of the network, consistent with the Pareto principle, whereby a fraction of the inputs generates a large proportion of the effects. Our results demonstrate that simple multivariate models provide nontrivial information about cryptocurrency market dynamics, and that these dynamics largely depend upon a few key high-influence coins.

Physics and Society,Statistical Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the application effect of multivariate linear models in constructing causal networks in the cryptocurrency market. Specifically, the author hopes to reveal the dependency relationships and causal structures in cryptocurrency price data by applying the Vector Autoregression (VAR) model, thereby providing a profound understanding of market dynamics and identifying highly - influential subnetworks. In addition, the research also aims to explore whether simple linear models can capture the complexity of the cryptocurrency market and how these models are related to factors such as market capitalization.

By comparing different linear causal network construction methods (including correlation - based networks and Transfer Entropy (TE) - based networks), the paper evaluates the advantages of the VAR model in controlling spurious regression effects. The research results show that, despite the high complexity of the cryptocurrency market, simple multivariate linear models can still provide non - trivial information and reveal the importance of key highly - influential cryptocurrencies in the market. These findings are of great significance for understanding the dynamic mechanisms, risk management, and investment strategies in the cryptocurrency market.