Abstract:Problem definition: This paper explores the impact of competition between platforms in the sharing economy. Examples include the cases of Uber and Lyft in the context of ride-sharing platforms. In particular, we consider competition between two platforms that offer a common service (e.g., rides) through a set of independent service providers (e.g., drivers) to a market of customers. Each platform sets a price that is charged to customers for obtaining service provided by a driver. A portion of that price is paid to the driver that delivers the service. Both customers’ and drivers’ utilities are sensitive to the payment terms set by the platform and are also sensitive to congestion in the system (given by the relative number of customers and drivers in the market). We consider two possible settings. The first one, termed “single-homing,” assumes that drivers work through a single platform. In the second setting, termed “multi-homing” (or “multi-apping” as it is known in practice), drivers deliver service through both platforms. Academic/Practical Relevance: This is one of the first papers to study competition and multi-homing in the presence of congestion effects typically observed in the sharing economy. We leverage the model to study some practical questions that have received significant press attention (and stirred some controversies) in the ride-sharing industry. The first involves the issue of surge pricing. The second involves the increasingly common practice of drivers choosing to operate on multiple platforms (multi-homing). Methodology: We formulate our problem as a pricing game between two platforms and employ the concept of Nash equilibrium to analyze equilibrium outcomes in various settings. Results: In both the single-homing and multi-homing settings, we study the equilibrium prices that emerge from the competitive interaction between the platforms and explore the supply and demand outcomes that can arise at equilibrium. We build on these equilibrium results to study the impact of surge pricing in response to a surge in demand and to examine the incentives at play when drivers engage in multi-homing. Managerial Implications: We find that raising prices in response to a surge in demand makes drivers and customers better off than if platforms were constrained to charge the same prices that would arise under normal demand levels. We also compare drivers’ and customers’ performance when all drivers either single-home or all multi-home. We find that, while individual drivers may have an incentive to multi-home, all players are worse off when all drivers multi-home. We conclude by proposing an incentive mechanism to discourage multi-homing.

On the interplay between pricing, competition and QoS in ride-hailing

Pricing, competition and market segmentation in ride hailing

Coordinating Supply and Demand in Ride-Sourcing Markets with Pre-Assigned Pooling Service and Traffic Congestion Externality

Dynamic Optimization Strategies for On-Demand Ride Services Platform: Surge Pricing, Commission Rate, and Incentives

On Network Effects in the Ride-Sourcing Market with Heterogeneous Users

Simulating On-Demand Ride Services in a Manhattan-like Urban Network Considering Traffic Dynamics

Optimal Spatial Pricing for an On-demand Ride-sourcing Service Platform

A Bi-Level Optimization Model for Ride-Sourcing Platform’s Spatial Pricing Strategy

Modeling Network Equilibrium of Competitive Ride-Sourcing Market with Heterogeneous Transportation Network Companies

Modeling Morning Commute Problem with Real-Time Ridesharing Services

A Stochastic Evolutionary Dynamic Game Model for Analyzing the Ride-Sourcing Market with Limited Platform Reputation

Competition Between Two-Sided Platforms Under Demand and Supply Congestion Effects

Nash-stackelberg game perspective on pricing strategies for ride-hailing and aggregation platforms under bundle mode

Pricing in Ride-sharing Markets : Effects of network competition and autonomous vehicles

Ride-sourcing market equilibrium analysis and optimization under immediate matching strategies

Hierarchical Pricing Game for Balancing the Charging of Ride-Hailing Electric Fleets

Competition and evolution in ride-hailing market: A dynamic duopoly game model

Wild goose chase or not? Equilibrium in a hybrid ride-hailing market

Flow Equilibria via Online Surge Pricing

Two-stage Stochastic Matching and Pricing with Applications to Ride Hailing

Dynamic pricing and matching in ride‐hailing platforms