Abstract:In our lives, we encounter various stressors that may cause negative mental and bodily reactions to make us feel frustrated, angry, or irritated. Effective methods to manage or reduce stress and anxiety are essential for a healthy life, and several stress-management approaches are found to be useful for stress relief, such as meditation, taking a rest, walking around nature, or even breaking things in a smash room. Previous research has revealed that certain experiences in virtual reality (VR) are effective for reducing stress as traditional real-world methods. However, it is still unclear how the stress relief effects are associated with other factors like individual user profile in terms of different treatment activities. In this paper, we report our findings from a formal user study that investigates the effects of two virtual activities: (1) VR Meditation and (2) VR Smash Room experience, compared with a traditional Sitting-in-Silence method. Our results show that VR Meditation has a better stress relief effect compared to VR Smash Room and Sitting-in-Silence, and the effects of the treatments are correlated with the participants' personalities. We discuss the findings and implications addressing potential benefits/impacts of different stress-relief activities in VR.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore the effectiveness of virtual reality (VR) activities in alleviating stress and compare them with traditional methods. Specifically, the study evaluates the effects of two VR activities—VR meditation and VR destruction room experience—on stress relief compared to traditional sitting meditation through formal user experiments. Additionally, the study investigates how individual characteristics (such as personality traits) influence the effectiveness of these stress management methods. ### Research Background and Problem Statement 1. **Importance of Stress Management**: - Various stressors in life can lead to negative psychological and physical reactions, such as depression, anger, or irritability. - Effective stress management methods are crucial for a healthy life. Previous studies have shown that methods like meditation, rest, walking in nature, and even breaking objects in a destruction room can effectively alleviate stress. 2. **Application of Virtual Reality**: - Virtual reality technology has been widely used in the field of mental health treatment, including anxiety management, acrophobia treatment, and post-traumatic stress disorder therapy. - Previous research suggests that certain VR experiences may be as effective, if not more effective, than traditional methods in alleviating stress. 3. **Research Questions**: - **RQ1**: Are stress management methods in virtual reality more effective in alleviating stress compared to traditional methods (such as rest) in the real world? - **RQ2**: How do individual characteristics (such as personality traits) influence the effectiveness of stress management methods? ### Experimental Design The study recruited 40 participants to experience one of three stress relief conditions: sitting meditation, VR meditation, and VR destruction room experience. All participants underwent a cognitive challenge task (PASAT) before experiencing one of the three stress relief methods and reported their emotional changes before and after the experience. ### Key Findings 1. **VR Meditation is the Most Effective**: - Results showed that VR meditation was significantly more effective in alleviating stress compared to VR destruction room experience and sitting meditation. - This finding differs from previous research on physical activities in virtual reality alleviating fatigue and reducing depression. 2. **Impact of Personality Traits**: - There was a significant or moderate correlation between stress relief effectiveness and participants' personality traits. - Different personality traits may influence individuals' responses to different stress relief methods. ### Discussion and Significance The authors discussed the study results and proposed the potential impact and practical applications of different VR activities in stress relief. Although the VR destruction room experience was considered an interesting activity, its effectiveness was not as expected, possibly due to individual differences. The study results provide a reference for the future development of more effective virtual reality stress management tools.

Exploring the Effects of VR Activities on Stress Relief: A Comparison of Sitting-in-Silence, VR Meditation, and VR Smash Room

P86: Effect of Virtual Reality on Stress Reduction and Change of Physiological Parameters Including Heart Rate Variability in People With High Stress: An Open Randomized Crossover Trial

Effects of the Visual Character of Transitional Spaces on Human Stress Recovery in a Virtual Reality Environment

Virtual Reality and Stress Management: A Systematic Review

Beyond sight: Comparing traditional virtual reality and immersive multi-sensory environments in stress reduction of university students

Reducing Stress and Anxiety in the Metaverse: A Systematic Review of Meditation, Mindfulness and Virtual Reality

Restorative effect of interactive virtual reality natural environment experience on psychophysiological responses

Virtual reality environments for stress reduction and management: a scoping review

Automated Stress Recognition Using Supervised Learning Classifiers by Interactive Virtual Reality Scenes.

Effectiveness of Mindfulness-Based Virtual Reality Training on Stress, Anxiety, and Depression among Chinese University Students

Contrasting Cognitive, Behavioral, and Physiological Responses to Breathwork vs. Naturalistic Stimuli in Reflective Chamber and VR Headset Environments: Randomized Control Study

A Virtual Reality Game as a Tool to Assess Physiological Correlations of Stress

Brief Virtual Reality Mindfulness is More Effective than Audio Mindfulness and Colouring in Reducing Stress in University Students

Effect of a Virtual Reality-Based Restorative Environment on the Emotional and Cognitive Recovery of Individuals with Mild-to-Moderate Anxiety and Depression

The impact of virtual reality scenes on stress response characteristics of individuals with different personality traits

Stress Management Using Virtual Reality-Based Attention Training

Enhancing Well-Being: A Comparative Study of Virtual Reality Chromotherapy Rooms with Static, Dynamic, and Empty Environments

Effects of Virtual Reality (VR)-Based Meditation on Sleep Quality, Stress, and Autonomic Nervous System Balance in Nursing Students

Virtual stressors with real impact: what virtual reality-based biobehavioral research can teach us about typical and atypical stress responsivity

Design and Evaluation of the Mental Relaxation VR Scenes Using Forehead EEG Features

Break Times: Virtual Reality Art Therapy