Max Uetrecht,Igor F. Herbut,Emmanuel Stamou,Michael M. Scherer
Abstract:Evidence for relativistic quantum criticality of antiferromagnetism and superconductivity in two-dimensional Dirac fermion systems has been found in large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. However, the corresponding ($2+1$)-dimensional Gross--Neveu--Yukawa field theory with $N_f=2$ four-component Dirac fermions coupled to two triplets of order parameters does not exhibit a renormalization group fixed point at one-loop order. Instead, the theory only features a critical point for a large or very small fractional number of fermion flavors $N_f$, which disappears for a broad range of flavor numbers around the physical case, $N_f=2$, due to fixed-point annihilation. This raises the question on how to explain the observed scaling collapse in the quantum Monte Carlo data. Here, we extend previous renormalization-group analyses by studying a generalized model at two-loop order in $4-\epsilon$ spacetime dimensions. We determine the $\epsilon$ correction to the upper and lower critical flavor numbers for the fixed-point annihilation and find that they both go towards the physical case $N_f=2$. However, this only happens very slowly, such that an extrapolation to $\epsilon=1$ still suggests the absence of criticality in $2+1$ dimensions. Thereby, we consolidate the finding that the continuum field theory does not feature a stable renormalization-group fixed point and no true quantum criticality would be expected for the considered system. We briefly discuss a possible reconciliation in terms of a complex conformal field theory. Further, we also explore the fixed-point structure in an enlarged theory space and identify a candidate stable fixed-point solution.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether there is SO(4) quantum criticality in the two - dimensional Dirac semimetal system. Specifically, the researchers found evidence of relativistic quantum criticality of antiferromagnetism and superconductivity in the two - dimensional Dirac fermion system in large - scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. However, the corresponding (2 + 1)-dimensional Gross - Neveu - Yukawa field theory does not show a renormalization group fixed point under a one - layer approximation, and there are only critical points in the range of very small or very large fermion flavor numbers \(N_f\), and this range does not include the physically important case \(N_f = 2\). This raises the question of how to interpret the observed scaling collapse in the quantum Monte Carlo data.
To explore this problem, the author extended the previous renormalization group analysis. By studying a generalized model in \(4-\epsilon\) space - time dimensions, the author determined the \(\epsilon\) corrections of the upper and lower limit critical flavor numbers for fixed - point annihilation, and found that these critical flavor numbers all tend to the physical case \(N_f = 2\). However, this process is very slow, so that even when \(\epsilon = 1\), it is still implied that there is no criticality in 2 + 1 dimensions. Therefore, the author has consolidated the view that there is no stable renormalization group fixed point in the continuous field theory, that is, for the considered system, true quantum criticality should not be expected. In addition, the author also briefly discussed a possible reconciliation scheme, that is, through the complex conformal field theory, and explored the fixed - point structure in the extended theory space, and identified a candidate stable fixed - point solution.
### Main research methods:
1. **Model construction**: A (2 + 1)-dimensional Gross - Neveu - Yukawa field theory including two four - component Dirac fermions coupled with two triplet order parameters was studied.
2. **Renormalization group analysis**: Renormalization group analysis was carried out in \(4-\epsilon\) dimensions through a two - layer approximation, and the two - layer \(\beta\) functions and anomalous dimensions were calculated.
3. **Fixed - point analysis**: Fixed - point analysis was carried out in the symmetric subspace and the full parameter space respectively, especially for the case of \(N_f = 2\) corresponding to graphene.
### Main conclusions:
- Under a one - layer approximation, the model has no stable renormalization group fixed point near the physically important \(N_f = 2\).
- Through a two - layer approximation, it was found that the upper and lower limit critical flavor numbers for fixed - point annihilation tend to the physical case \(N_f = 2\), but this process is very slow, and even when \(\epsilon = 1\), it still implies that there is no criticality in 2 + 1 dimensions.
- The research results support the view that there is no stable renormalization group fixed point in the continuous field theory, that is, for the considered system, true quantum criticality should not be expected.
### Possible explanations:
- The lattice model corresponds to different continuous field theories, such as theories containing additional topological terms.
- The one - layer renormalization group analysis may have missed the underlying fixed points, which may be recovered in higher - layer approximations.
- The transitions observed in the lattice model may be weak first - order phase transitions, only mimicking critical behavior.
These findings provide a new perspective for understanding the quantum critical behavior in two - dimensional Dirac semimetals and provide directions for further research.