Disentangling patchy reionization signatures from primordial gravitational waves using CMB $E$-mode and $B$-mode polarization

Divesh Jain,Suvodip Mukherjee,Tirthankar Roy Choudhury
2023-10-25
Abstract:The detection of large angular scale $B$-mode in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) polarization signal will open a direct window into not only the primary CMB anisotropies caused by the primordial gravitational waves (PGW) originating in the epoch of inflation, but also the secondary anisotropies imprinted during the epoch of cosmic reionization. The existence of patchiness in the electron density during reionization produces a unique distortion in the CMB $B$-mode polarization, which can be distinguished from the PGW signal with the aid of spatial frequency modes. In this work, we employ an $EB$ estimator by combining $E$-mode and $B$-mode polarization for the $\tau$ power spectrum signal generated in a photon-conserving semi-numerical reionization model called SCRIPT. We developed a Bayesian framework for the joint detection of the PGW and reionization signal from CMB observations and show the efficacy of this technique for upcoming CMB experiments. We find that, for our model, the $\tau$ power spectrum signal effectively tracks the inhomogeneous electron density field, allowing for robust constraints on the patchy $B$-mode signal. Further, our results indicate that employing the $EB$ estimator for the $\tau$ signal will facilitate ground-based CMB-S4 to detect the patchy $B$-mode signal at approximately $\geq 2\sigma$ confidence level while observations with space-based PICO will improve this detection to $\geq 3\sigma$ going as high as $\geq 7\sigma$ for extreme reionization models. These findings not only highlight the future potential of these experiments to provide an improved picture of the reionization process but also have important implications towards an unbiased measurement of $r$.
Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to solve the problem of how to distinguish the inhomogeneous signals generated by the reionization process from the signals generated by the primordial gravitational waves (PGW) in the polarization signals of the cosmic microwave background (CMB). Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Distinguishing inhomogeneous reionization signals from primordial gravitational wave signals**: - The inhomogeneous distribution of the free - electron density during the reionization process will produce a unique distorted signal in the 𝐵 - mode polarization of the CMB. This signal can be distinguished from the primordial gravitational wave signal by the spatial frequency mode. - The paper extracts the 𝜏 power - spectrum signal in the reionization process by using an 𝐸𝐵 estimator in combination with 𝐸 - mode and 𝐵 - mode polarization signals. 2. **Developing a Bayesian framework**: - In order to jointly detect the primordial gravitational waves and reionization signals, the paper develops a Bayesian framework. This framework can effectively extract these signals from the CMB observation data and evaluate the detection capabilities of future CMB experiments. 3. **Evaluating the detection capabilities of future CMB experiments**: - The paper evaluates the detection capabilities of upcoming CMB experiments (such as CMB - S4 and PICO) in different delensing scenarios. The results show that for the reionization signals in the model, CMB - S4 can detect the inhomogeneous 𝐵 - mode signal at a confidence level of approximately ≥2𝜎, while PICO can increase it to ≥3𝜎, and even reach ≥7𝜎 in the extreme reionization model. 4. **Optimizing estimator development**: - The paper develops optimal estimators for jointly detecting inhomogeneous and primordial 𝐵 - mode signals. These estimators perform well in the multipole range ℓ∼2−200 and can effectively distinguish these two signals. ### Key techniques and methods - **𝐸𝐵 estimator**: Combine 𝐸 - mode and 𝐵 - mode polarization signals and use the 𝐸𝐵 estimator to extract the 𝜏 power - spectrum signal in the reionization process. - **Bayesian framework**: Develop a Bayesian framework for jointly detecting primordial gravitational waves and reionization signals. - **Numerical simulation**: Use an efficient semi - numerical reionization model (SCRIPT) to generate reionization maps, thereby simulating CMB signals. - **Noise modeling**: Consider the influence of instrument noise on the detection capabilities, especially in different delensing scenarios. ### Conclusion Through the above methods, the paper shows the potential of future CMB experiments (such as CMB - S4 and PICO) in detecting inhomogeneous 𝐵 - mode signals in the reionization process. These results are not only helpful for better understanding the reionization process, but also of great significance for unbiased measurement of the tensor - scalar ratio (𝑟) of primordial gravitational waves.