Uncertainty study for the Galactic calibration of radio antenna arrays in astroparticle physics

Max Büsken,Tomáš Fodran,Tim Huege

2023-08-16

Abstract:In recent years, arrays of radio antennas operating in the MHz regime have shown great potential as detectors in astroparticle physics. In particular, they fulfill an important role in the indirect detection of ultra-high energy cosmic rays. For a proper determination of the energy scale of the primary particles, accurate absolute calibration of radio detectors is crucial. Galactic calibration - i.e., using the Galaxy-dominated radio sky as a reference source - will potentially be the standard method for this task. However, uncertainties in the strength of the Galactic radio emission lead to uncertainties in the absolute calibration of the radio detectors and, thus, in the energy scale of the cosmic-ray measurements. To quantify these uncertainties, we present a study comparing seven sky models in the radio-frequency range of 30 to 408 MHz. By conversion to the locally visible sky, we estimate the uncertainties for the cases of the radio antenna arrays of GRAND, IceCube, LOFAR, OVRO-LWA, the Pierre Auger Observatory, RNO-G and SKA-low. Finally, we discuss the applicability of the Galactic calibration, for example, regarding the influence of the quiet Sun.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to accurately assess the uncertainties in the Galactic calibration method to ensure the absolute calibration accuracy of radio antenna arrays in cosmic particle physics research**.

Specifically, the paper focuses on the absolute calibration of radio antenna arrays using Galactic - dominated radio sources as reference sources. Since the uncertainty of the Galactic radio radiation intensity can affect the absolute calibration of radio antenna arrays and, in turn, the energy scale of cosmic - ray measurements, it is necessary to quantify these uncertainties. By comparing seven different radio sky models, the authors estimated the uncertainties in Galactic radio radiation predictions in the 30 - to - 408 - MHz frequency range and discussed the effects of different geographical locations and frequency ranges on these uncertainties.

### Key issues
1. **Importance of Galactic calibration**: Galactic calibration is a long - term method that does not require special calibration activities and can provide a stable reference signal.
2. **Sources of uncertainty**: There are uncertainties in the prediction of Galactic radio radiation intensity, which will affect the absolute calibration accuracy of radio antenna arrays.
3. **Differences within the frequency range**: Uncertainties vary in different frequency ranges, especially in the low - frequency band (such as 30 - 80 MHz), where the uncertainties are larger.
4. **Impact of geographical location**: The Galactic radio signals observed at different geographical locations are also different. Especially in low - latitude areas, the Galactic center is higher and the differences between models are smaller.

### Research methods
To quantify these uncertainties, the authors:
- Compared seven publicly available radio sky models (LFmap, GSM (2008), GSM (2016), LFSM, GMOSS, SSM, ULSA), and compared the all - sky maps of these models at different frequencies.
- Calculated the average sky temperature of each model and defined a ratio to estimate the uncertainty of the absolute temperature scale.
- Considered the specific parameters of different radio antenna arrays (such as GRAND, IceCube, LOFAR, OVRO - LWA, Pierre Auger Observatory, RNO - G, SKA - low) to further refine the uncertainty estimates.

### Main conclusions
- The globally estimated uncertainty of the Galactic radio radiation brightness temperature is 14.3%.
- The uncertainty for the particle energy scale is approximately 7% because the energy scale is proportional to the square root of the signal power.
- The specific uncertainties of different radio antenna arrays are between 11.7% and 21.5%.
- In addition to Galactic radio sources, other radio sources such as the Sun, Jupiter, and the ionosphere may also affect Galactic calibration. In particular, the quiet - day radiation of the Sun makes a significant contribution to the background signal at higher frequencies.

Through these studies, the authors demonstrated the competitiveness of the Galactic calibration method in terms of accuracy and provided important reference data for future radio antenna array calibrations.