Abstract:Programmable packet schedulers have emerged in the context of Software-Defined Networking (SDN) and diverse service requirements in today's networks. With a programmable packet scheduler, network operators can apply different scheduling algorithms on the switches. To support a large variety of packet scheduling algorithms, the use of a packet scheduler like PIFO (Push-In First-Out) has been adopted, which serves packets based on their associated priority ranks. Recently, for the concern of priority rank scalability and implementation complexity, a new class of packet schedulers that closely approximate PIFO have been proposed. However, the approximate PIFO schemes may lead to a sub-optimal packet scheduling order and introduce packet inversions. In this paper, we evaluate the inversion impact on Start-Time Fair Queueing (STFQ), an efficient approximation of Weighted Fair Queueing to allocate bandwidth fairly and achieve low maximum delay, when it is used in the approximate PIFO schemes. Our analysis validates the deterioration on the performance goals of STFQ attributed to packet inversions and provides a theoretical bound for the discrepancy caused by these inversions in the fair and delay guarantees offered by STFQ. Based on our simulation results, we demonstrate that the packet inversions in approximate PIFO schemes impair the fairness of bandwidth allocation and the worst-case throughput difference in our simulation exhibits a bias of up to 34% of the total available bandwidth. We further show that the packet inversions result in a 3-fold increase in the maximum end-to-end packet delay in approximate PIFO schemes such as SP-PIFO and AFQ.

RIFO: Pushing the Efficiency of Programmable Packet Schedulers

Vpifo: Virtualized Packet Scheduler for Programmable Hierarchical Scheduling in High-Speed Networks

Everything Matters in Programmable Packet Scheduling

PIPO - Efficient Programmable Scheduling for Time Sensitive Networking.

RFT: Toward Highly Reliable Flow Data Transmission in Network Measurement

Minimizing the Communication Overhead of Iterative Scheduling Algorithms for Input-Queued Switches.

An Efficient Single-Iteration Single-Bit Request Scheduling Algorithm for Input-Queued Switches

Inversion impact of approximate PIFO to Start-Time Fair Queueing

Formal Abstractions for Packet Scheduling

BMW Tree: Large-scale, High-throughput and Modular PIFO Implementation Using Balanced Multi-Way Sorting Tree.

Fair Scheduling for Delay-Sensitive VoIP Traffic

DRR-SFF: A Practical Scheduling Algorithm to Improve the Performance of Short Flows

Rapier: Integrating routing and scheduling for coflow-aware data center networks

Study on a Packet Scheduling Algorithm in High Performance Routers

Implementation of Packet-Fair Queuing Algorithms in High Speed Routers Based on Discrete Rates and Packet Lengths Group Architectures

Eiffel: Efficient and Flexible Software Packet Scheduling

HOBRP: A Hardware Optimized Packet Scheduler That Provides Tunable End-to-end Delay Bound

Meeting Coflow Deadlines in Data Center Networks with Policy-Based Selective Completion.

PIFO Output Queued Switch Emulation by a One-cell-Crosspoint Buffered Crossbar Switch

Pushing the Performance Limits of Datacenter Networks with Fine-grained Priority Assignment

A Resource Pooling Switch Architecture with High Performance Scheduler