Affective Visualization Design: Leveraging the Emotional Impact of Data

Xingyu Lan,Yanqiu Wu,Nan Cao
2023-08-05
Abstract:In recent years, more and more researchers have reflected on the undervaluation of emotion in data visualization and highlighted the importance of considering human emotion in visualization design. Meanwhile, an increasing number of studies have been conducted to explore emotion-related factors. However, so far, this research area is still in its early stages and faces a set of challenges, such as the unclear definition of key concepts, the insufficient justification of why emotion is important in visualization design, and the lack of characterization of the design space of affective visualization design. To address these challenges, first, we conducted a literature review and identified three research lines that examined both emotion and data visualization. We clarified the differences between these research lines and kept 109 papers that studied or discussed how data visualization communicates and influences emotion. Then, we coded the 109 papers in terms of how they justified the legitimacy of considering emotion in visualization design (i.e., why emotion is important) and identified five argumentative perspectives. Based on these papers, we also identified 61 projects that practiced affective visualization design. We coded these design projects in three dimensions, including design fields (where), design tasks (what), and design methods (how), to explore the design space of affective visualization design.
Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on several key challenges in the field of emotion - based visual design: 1. **Clarity of Definitions and Concepts**: In the current field of emotion - based visual research, there is an issue of inconsistent use of concepts. For example, the term "emotion - based visual design" has different meanings and application scopes in different literatures, which hinders effective communication among researchers. 2. **The Legitimacy of Emotion in Visual Design**: Traditionally, the evaluation criteria for data visualization emphasize rational indicators such as accuracy and efficiency, while the status and importance of emotion in it are questioned. Some viewpoints believe that emotional design may undermine the objectivity of data. Therefore, it is necessary to systematically review the existing literature and demonstrate why it is important to consider emotion in visual design. 3. **The Operationalization of Emotional Design**: Currently, there is a lack of clear guidance on how to specifically implement emotion - based visual design. For example, in which fields this design can be applied, what tasks it can accomplish, and how to carry out the design. Only by answering these questions can the existing knowledge and practice be sorted out and specific strategies and techniques be provided for designers. To address these challenges, the paper has carried out the following work: - **Literature Review**: Through literature review, three research lines were identified, all of which explored the relationship between emotion and data visualization. The differences between these research lines were clarified, and emotion - based visual design (data visualization aiming to convey and influence emotions) was determined as the research focus of this paper. - **Perspectives for Demonstrating the Importance of Emotion**: 109 related papers were coded, and arguments supporting emotion - based visual design were summarized from five perspectives (application, usefulness, rhetoric, sociology, humanities). - **Exploring the Design Space**: Based on 109 papers, 61 emotion - based visual design projects were identified, and these projects were coded from three dimensions: design field, design task, and design method to explore the design space of emotion - based visual design. Through these efforts, the paper aims to clarify the value of emotion in visual design and provide specific design implications for designers.