A scalable system to measure contrail formation on a per-flight basis

Scott Geraedts,Erica Brand,Thomas R. Dean,Sebastian Eastham,Carl Elkin,Zebediah Engberg,Ulrike Hager,Ian Langmore,Kevin McCloskey,Joe Yue-Hei Ng,John C. Platt,Tharun Sankar,Aaron Sarna,Marc Shapiro,Nita Goyal

2023-12-19

Abstract:Persistent contrails make up a large fraction of aviation's contribution to global warming. We describe a scalable, automated detection and matching (ADM) system to determine from satellite data whether a flight has made a persistent contrail. The ADM system compares flight segments to contrails detected by a computer vision algorithm running on images from the GOES-16 Advanced Baseline Imager. We develop a 'flight matching' algorithm and use it to label each flight segment as a 'match' or 'non-match'. We perform this analysis on 1.6 million flight segments. The result is an analysis of which flights make persistent contrails several orders of magnitude larger than any previous work. We assess the agreement between our labels and available prediction models based on weather forecasts. Shifting air traffic to avoid regions of contrail formation has been proposed as a possible mitigation with the potential for very low cost/ton-CO2e. Our findings suggest that imperfections in these prediction models increase this cost/ton by about an order of magnitude. Contrail avoidance is a cost-effective climate change mitigation even with this factor taken into account, but our results quantify the need for more accurate contrail prediction methods and establish a benchmark for future development.

Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the contribution of the aviation industry to global warming, especially through persistent contrails formed during the flight of airplanes. Specifically, the objectives of the paper are:

1. **Develop a scalable Automatic Detection and Matching (ADM) system**: Use satellite data to determine whether a specific flight has formed persistent contrails. This system uses images from the GOES - 16 Advanced Baseline Imager (ABI) and detects contrails through computer vision algorithms.

2. **Evaluate the accuracy of existing prediction models**: Existing prediction models are based on weather forecast data to predict which flights will form contrails. The paper evaluates the precision and recall of these models by comparing the actually observed contrails with the prediction results.

3. **Quantify the cost impact of the imperfection of prediction models**: The research finds that the imperfection of prediction models will lead to an increase in the cost per ton of carbon dioxide equivalent by about an order of magnitude. Nevertheless, avoiding contrails is still a cost - effective climate change mitigation measure.

4. **Provide large - scale empirical analysis**: The paper has analyzed 1.6 million flight segments within 168 hours, which is the largest and most detailed analysis of contrail formation so far.

Through these objectives, the paper aims to provide the aviation industry with more accurate contrail prediction methods and provide a scientific basis for formulating effective climate change mitigation strategies.