The Oxygen Bottleneck for Technospheres

Amedeo Balbi,Adam Frank

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-023-02112-8

2023-12-28

Abstract:As oxygen is essential for respiration and metabolism for multicellular organisms on Earth, its presence may be crucial for the development of a complex biosphere on other planets. And because life itself, through photosynthesis, contributed to creating our oxygen-rich atmosphere, oxygen has long been considered as a possible biosignature. Here we consider the relationship between atmospheric oxygen and the development of technology. We argue that only planets with substantial oxygen partial pressure ($p_{\rm O_2}$) will be capable of developing advanced technospheres and hence technosignatures that we can detect. But open-air combustion (needed, for example, for metallurgy), is possible only in Earth-like atmospheres when $p_{\rm O_2}\ge 18\%$. This limit is higher than the one needed to sustain a complex biosphere and multicellular organisms. We further review other possible planetary atmospheric compositions and conclude that oxygen is the most likely candidate for the evolution of technological species. Thus, the presence of $p_{\rm O_2}\ge 18\%$ in exoplanet atmospheres may represent a contextual prior required for the planning and interpretation of technosignature searches.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics,Popular Physics