Abstract:Recently, it was discovered that lower-dimensional versions of Lovelock gravity exist as scalar-tensor theories that are examples of Horndeski gravity. We study the thermodynamics of the static black hole solutions in these theories up to cubic order through Euclidean methods. Considering solutions with spherical, planar and hyperbolic event horizons ($k=+1, 0, -1$), we show that the universality of the thermodynamics for planar black holes ($k=0$) and the extended 1st law that include the variation of the couplings together with their associated potentials hold also in lower dimensions. We find that in $D=4, 6$ where the 2nd- and the 3rd-order Lovelock Lagrangians are boundary terms respectively, the Smarr relation is modified since the entropy is not a homogenous function in these dimensions. We also present a derivation of the Smarr relation and its modified version based on the global scaling properties of the reduced action that is used to obtain the solutions consistently. Unlike the other hairy black hole solutions that have been analyzed before, despite the terms in the reduced action that break the scaling symmetry, the derivation still follows from a conserved Noether charge.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the thermodynamic properties of static black - hole solutions in lower - dimensional Lovelock gravity. Specifically, the authors focus on:
1. **Universality**: Explore whether the thermodynamic properties of planar black holes (i.e., black holes with the event - horizon curvature parameter \(\kappa = 0\)) are also universal in lower dimensions.
2. **Extended first law**: Verify whether the extended first law that includes the variation of coupling constants still holds in lower dimensions.
3. **Smarr relation**: Study whether the Smarr relation is modified in \(d = 4, 6\) dimensions due to the entropy not being a homogeneous function, and derive the Smarr relation and its modified version in these dimensions.
4. **Scale symmetry**: Derive the Smarr relation and its modified version from the reduced action based on global scale symmetry.
### Specific problem analysis
#### 1. Universality
The authors studied whether the thermodynamic properties of planar black holes (\(\kappa = 0\)) remain unchanged in lower dimensions. They found that in lower dimensions, although the forms of the solutions are different, their thermodynamic properties are the same as the static solutions in general relativity.
#### 2. Extended first law
The authors verified whether the extended first law that includes the variation of coupling constants still holds in lower dimensions. They studied the thermodynamic properties of static black - hole solutions by the Euclidean method and found that the extended first law can be easily derived in these theories.
#### 3. Smarr relation
In \(d = 4, 6\) dimensions, since the entropy is not a homogeneous function, the Smarr relation needs to be modified. The authors derived the Smarr relation and its modified version in these dimensions and showed how to derive these relations from global scale symmetry.
#### 4. Scale symmetry
The authors used global scale symmetry to derive the Smarr relation and its modified version from the reduced action. This method is applicable not only to planar black holes but also to solutions with non - planar event horizons. Even in the presence of terms that break scale symmetry, for the solutions studied, the charge function is still conserved on - shell, so the Smarr relation can be directly derived.
### Conclusion
Through these studies, the authors not only verified the thermodynamic properties of static black - hole solutions in lower - dimensional Lovelock gravity but also revealed some special behaviors in these theories. In particular, even in the presence of terms that break scale symmetry, the charge function is still conserved on - shell, which has not been observed in previous studies. These results provide an important theoretical basis for further understanding Lovelock gravity and its applications in lower dimensions.