Understanding the worst-kept secret of high-frequency trading

Sergio Pulido,Mathieu Rosenbaum,Emmanouil Sfendourakis
2024-07-23
Abstract:Volume imbalance in a limit order book is often considered as a reliable indicator for predicting future price moves. In this work, we seek to analyse the nuances of the relationship between prices and volume imbalance. To this end, we study a market-making problem which allows us to view the imbalance as an optimal response to price moves. In our model, there is an underlying efficient price driving the mid-price, which follows the model with uncertainty zones. A single market maker knows the underlying efficient price and consequently the probability of a mid-price jump in the future. She controls the volumes she quotes at the best bid and ask prices. Solving her optimization problem allows us to understand endogenously the price-imbalance connection and to confirm in particular that it is optimal to quote a predictive imbalance. Our model can also be used by a platform to select a suitable tick size, which is known to be a crucial topic in financial regulation. The value function of the market maker's control problem can be viewed as a family of functions, indexed by the level of the market maker's inventory, solving a coupled system of PDEs. We show existence and uniqueness of classical solutions to this coupled system of equations. In the case of a continuous inventory, we also prove uniqueness of the market maker's optimal control policy.
Trading and Market Microstructure
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores an issue in high-frequency trading known as the "least secret secret"—namely, the role of volume imbalance in predicting price movements. The authors aim to delve into the relationship between volume imbalance and price movements by constructing a market maker model and verifying whether volume imbalance can serve as an effective predictor of future price movements. Specifically, the main research objectives of the paper include: 1. **Understanding Volume Imbalance**: The authors study how volume imbalance can serve as the best response to future price movements through an optimization problem of a market maker. This helps in understanding the intrinsic link between volume imbalance and price movements. 2. **Optimal Quoting Strategy**: By analyzing the optimal control problem of the market maker, the study investigates how to achieve optimal volume imbalance by adjusting the quoted volumes at the best bid and ask prices. 3. **Determining Appropriate Tick Size**: The model can also be used to select an appropriate tick size (i.e., the smallest unit of price movement), which is of significant importance for financial regulation. 4. **Theoretical Results**: The paper proves the existence and uniqueness of the value function for the market maker's control problem and demonstrates the existence and uniqueness of the optimal control strategy. The paper employs a model that includes an uncertain region to describe market price movements and assumes that the market maker can observe an effective price that drives the changes in the mid-price. The market maker's goal is to maximize the exponential utility of her terminal wealth given a risk aversion coefficient. To achieve this goal, she needs to control the quoted volumes at the best bid and ask prices. Overall, this study provides a new perspective on understanding the complex relationship between volume imbalance and price movements and offers a theoretical basis for the quoting strategies of market makers.