Trace dynamics and its implications for my work of the last two decades

Stephen L. Adler

2023-10-11

Abstract:I review the basic ideas of "trace dynamics", as formulated in my 2004 Cambridge University Press book "Quantum Theory as an Emergent Phenomenon", and then discuss how they have influenced much of my work of the last two decades.

Quantum Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Book Review of Stephen L. Adler's, "Quantum theory as an emergent phenomenon."

Philip Pearle

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0602078

2006-02-07

Quantum Physics

Abstract:In Stephen Adler's book, "Quantum theory as an emergent phenomenon," the author starts from a classical mechanics structure and "derives" the formalism of quantum theory, together with wave function collapse dynamics, the latter providing the interpretation of quantum theory. A detailed outline of the author's argument is presented in this book review.
A Dynamic Histories Interpretation of Quantum Theory

Timothy D. Andersen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2009.04244

2020-08-21

Abstract:The problem of how to interpret quantum mechanics has persisted for a century. The disconnect between the wavefunction state vector and what is observed in experimental apparati has had no shortage of explanations. But all explanations so far fall short of a compelling and complete interpretation. In this letter, I present a novel interpretation called dynamic histories. I show mathematically how quantum mechanics can be reinterpreted as deterministically evolving dynamical world lines in a 5D universe. Quantum probabilities can be then be reinterpreted as stemming from ignorance of the state of our own world line. Meanwhile, the lack of observed superposition in experimental apparati is explained in that we only live on a single history with a definite set of properties. Hence, superposition is not an actual state of a particle but a model of ignorance as in classical probability theory. This explains nonlocal effects without superluminal communication. I also discuss how this relates to 5D Kaluza-Klein theory.

General Physics
A link between static and dynamical perturbation theory

Sebastian Gemsheim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/ad5865

2024-06-16

New Journal of Physics

Abstract:Dynamics, the physical change in time and a pillar of natural sciences, can be regarded as an emergent phenomenon when the system of interest is part of a larger, static one. This "relational approach to time", in which the system's environment provides a temporal reference, does not only provide insight into foundational issues of physics, but holds the potential for a deeper theoretical understanding as it intimately links statics and dynamics. Reinforcing the significance of this connection, we demonstrate, based on recent progress [Phys. Rev. Lett. 131, 140202 (2023)], the role of emergent time as a vital link between time-independent and time-dependent perturbation theory in quantum mechanics. We calculate first order contributions, which are often the most significant, and discuss the issue of degenerate spectra. Based on our results, we envision future applications for the calculation of dynamical phenomena based on a single pure energy eigenstate.

physics, multidisciplinary
Expanding wave packets and the quantum to classical transition

John S Briggs

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6404/ad4f35

2024-05-23

European Journal of Physics

Abstract:The standard description of the transition from quantum to classical mechanics presented in most text books is the proof that the quantum expectation values of position and momentum obey equations of Newtonian form. This is the Ehrenfest Theorem. It is combined with the requirement that wave packets remain localised to describe a single particle moving according to classical mechanics. Hence, the natural spreading of wave packets is viewed as a quantum effect. In contradiction to this view, here it is argued that the spreading, where different momentum components separate, is the signature of the quantum to classical transition. The asymptotic spatial wave function becomes proportional to the initial momentum space wave function, which mirrors exactly the well-known far-field diffraction pattern in optics. Trajectories, defined as the locus of the normals to the expanding wave front, are used to illustrate the transition from quantum to classical motion. Again this is the analogue of the wave to beam transition in optics. It is suggested that this analysis of the quantum to classical transition should be incorporated routinely into introductory quantum mechanics courses.mechanics courses.

physics, multidisciplinary,education, scientific disciplines
The three and a half layers of dynamics : analog, digital, semi-digital, analog

T. P. Singh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1106.0911

2011-06-06

Abstract:Quantum theory is extremely successful in explaining most physical phenomena, and is not contradicted by any experiment. Yet, the theory has many puzzling features : the occurrence of probabilities, the unclear distinction between the microscopic and the macroscopic, the unexplained absence of superpositions in positions of macroscopic objects, the dependence of the theory on an external classical time, and the experimentally verified but peculiar `influence' outside the light-cone in EPR experiments. These puzzles point towards a conflict between quantum theory and our present understanding of spacetime structure, and suggest the existence of a deeper theory. In this essay we make the case that in the underlying theory the matter and spacetime degrees of freedom are non-commuting matrices, and yet the dynamics is analog. A digital quantum-theory like dynamics for matter as well as spacetime emerges in the statistical thermodynamic approximation to this deeper theory. When most of the matter clumps into macroscopic structures, it is shown to behave classically, and it induces classical dynamics on spacetime; this is the eventual analog limit, our macroscopic world. In between the digital layer and the uppermost analog layer is the realm of standard quantum theory - microscopic objects and their interaction with measuring apparatuses on a classical spacetime background : the semi-digital approximation. Such a multi-layered description of dynamics can explain the puzzling features of quantum theory, and is testable by ongoing laboratory experiments.

Quantum Physics
Markovian dynamics for a quantum/classical system and quantum trajectories

Alberto Barchielli

2024-05-29

Abstract:Quantum trajectory techniques have been used in the theory of open systems as a starting point for numerical computations and to describe the monitoring of a quantum system in continuous time. Here we extend this technique and use it to develop a general approach to the dynamics of quantum/classical hybrid systems. By using two coupled stochastic differential equations, we can describe a classical component and a quantum one which have their own intrinsic dynamics and which interact with each other. A mathematically rigorous construction is given, under the restriction of having a Markovian joint dynamics and of involving only bounded operators on the Hilbert space of the quantum component. An important feature is that, if the interaction allows for a flow of information from the quantum component to the classical one, necessarily the dynamics is dissipative. We show also how this theory is connected to a suitable hybrid dynamical semigroup, which reduces to a quantum dynamical semigroup in the purely quantum case and includes Liouville and Kolmogorov-Fokker-Plank equations in the purely classical case. Moreover, this semigroup allows to compare the proposed stochastic dynamics with various other proposals based on hybrid master equations. Some simple examples are constructed in order to show the variety of physical behaviours which can be described; in particular, a model presenting hidden entanglement is introduced.

Quantum Physics
On the geometrical hypotheses underlying wave functions and their emerging dynamics

Erico Goulart,Nelson Pinto-Neto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.100.125001

2019-11-20

Abstract:Classical mechanics for individual physical systems and quantum mechanics of non-relativistic particles are shown to be exceptional cases of a generalized dynamics described in terms of maps between two manifolds, the source being configuration space. The target space is argued to be 2-dimensional and flat, and their orthogonal directions are physically interpreted. All terms in the map equation have a geometrical meaning in the target space, and the pull-back of its rotational Killing one-form allows the construction of a velocity field in configuration space. Identification of this velocity field with tangent vectors in the source space leads to the dynamical law of motion. For a specific choice of an arbitrary scalar function present in the map equation, and using Cartesian coordinates in the target space, the map equation becomes linear and can be reduced to the Schrödinger equation. We link the bi-dimensionality of the target space with the essential non-locality of quantum mechanics. Many extensions of the framework here presented are immediate, with deep consequences yet to be explored.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
Shape Dynamics and The Universe: Foundations and Implications

Pooya Farokhi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2201.07979

2022-01-19

Abstract:Shape dynamics is an alternative background-independent approach to classical dynamics that implements Leibnizian philosophy and Mach's Principles. It is a formulation of the dynamics of the universe in terms of the intrinsic and relational degrees of freedom which are objectively observable and not properties defined with respect to an external frame of reference. Shape dynamics is not a very old field of study. Although it was already gradually coming alive out of Julian Barbour's early works on Mach's Principle back in the 1980s, it was invigorated by a series of rigorous works in the last decade. This work is an exhaustive review of the historical and conceptual underpinning of the theory that extends to Leibniz and Newton's philosophy, and the currently established formulation of the theory, together with some of the major results of its cosmological applications. The structure of this work consists of two parts: In the first one we cover the foundations and the formulation of the theory (both the field and particle ontology), and in the second one we study its applications and reflect on the resolution of the problem of the arrow of time. We end our journey by contemplating some recent ideas and prospects for further developing the theory.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Understanding multiple timescales in quantum dissipative dynamics: Insights from quantum trajectories

Matthew Gerry,Michael J. Kewming,Dvira Segal

2024-02-15

Abstract:Open quantum systems with nearly degenerate energy levels have been shown to exhibit long-lived metastable states in the approach to equilibrium, even when modelled with certain Lindblad-form quantum master equations. This is a result of dramatic separation of timescales due to differences between Liouvillian eigenvalues. These metastable states often have nonzero coherences which die off only in the long time limit once the system reaches thermal equilibrium. We examine two distinct situations that give rise to this effect: one in which dissipative dynamics couple together states only within a nearly degenerate subspace, and one in which they give rise to jumps over finite energy splittings, between separate nearly degenerate subspaces. We find, in each case, that a change of basis can often lead to a representation which more naturally captures the impact of the system-bath interaction than does the energy eigenbasis, revealing that separate timescales are associated with separate processes (e.g. decoherence into a non-energy eigenbasis, decay of population correlations to the initial state). This approach is paired with the inspection of quantum trajectories, which further provide intuition as to how open system evolution is characterized when coherent oscillations, thermal relaxation, and decoherence all occur simultaneously.

Quantum Physics
Quantum Mechanics in a New Light

Ulrich Mohrhoff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10699-016-9487-6

2017-04-30

Abstract:Although the present paper looks upon the formal apparatus of quantum mechanics as a calculus of correlations, it goes beyond a purely operationalist interpretation. Having established the consistency of the correlations with the existence of their correlata (measurement outcomes), and having justified the distinction between a domain in which outcome-indicating events occur and a domain whose properties only exist if their existence is indicated by such events, it explains the difference between the two domains as essentially the difference between the manifested world and its manifestation. A single, intrinsically undifferentiated Being manifests the macroworld by entering into reflexive spatial relations. This atemporal process implies a new kind of causality and sheds new light on the mysterious nonlocality of quantum mechanics. Unlike other realist interpretations, which proceed from an evolving-states formulation, the present interpretation proceeds from Feynman's formulation of the theory, and it introduces a new interpretive principle, replacing the collapse postulate and the eigenvalue--eigenstate link of evolving-states formulations. Applied to alternatives involving distinctions between regions of space, this principle implies that the spatiotemporal differentiation of the physical world is incomplete. Applied to alternatives involving distinctions between things, it warrants the claim that, intrinsically, all fundamental particles are identical in the strong sense of numerical identical. They are the aforementioned intrinsically undifferentiated Being, which manifests the macroworld by entering into reflexive spatial relations.

Quantum Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics
Disappearing Without a Trace: The Arrows of Time in Kent's Solution to the Lorentzian Quantum Reality Problem

Emily Adlam

2023-07-05

Abstract:Most existing proposals to explain the temporal asymmetries we see around us are sited within an approach to physics based on time evolution, and thus they typically put the asymmetry in at the beginning of time in the form of a special initial state. But there may be other possibilities for explaining temporal asymmetries if we don't presuppose the time evolution paradigm. In this article, we explore one such possibility, based on Kent's `final-measurement' interpretation of quantum mechanics. We argue that this approach potentially has the resources to explain the electromagnetic asymmetry, the thermodynamic asymmetry, the coarse-graining asymmetry, the fork asymmetry, the record asymmetry, and the cosmological asymmetry, and that the explanations it offers may potentially be better than explanations appealing to a special initial state. Our hope is that this example will encourage further exploration of novel approaches to temporal asymmetry outside of the time evolution paradigm.

History and Philosophy of Physics,Quantum Physics
Beyond the Newtonian Paradigm: A Statistical Mechanics of Emergence

Stuart A. Kauffman,Andrea Roli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2106.15271

2022-07-13

Abstract:Since Newton, all classical and quantum physics depends upon the "Newtonian Paradigm". Here the relevant variables of the system are identified. The boundary conditions creating the phase space of all possible values of the variables are defined. Then, given any initial condition, the differential equations of motion are integrated to yield an entailed trajectory in the phase space. It is fundamental to the Newtonian Paradigm that the set of possibilities that constitute the phase space is always definable and fixed ahead of time. All of this fails for the diachronic evolution of ever new adaptations in any biosphere. The central reason is that living cells achieve Constraint Closure and construct themselves. Living cells, evolving via heritable variation and Natural selection, adaptively construct new in the universe possibilities. The new possibilities are opportunities for new adaptations thereafter seized by heritable variation and Natural Selection. Surprisingly, we can neither define nor deduce the evolving phase spaces ahead of time. We can use no mathematics based on Set Theory to do so. These ever-new adaptations with ever-new relevant variables constitute the ever-changing phase space of evolving biospheres. Because of this, evolving biospheres are entirely outside the Newtonian Paradigm. One consequence is that for any universe such as ours there can be no Final Theory that entails all that comes to exist. The implications are large. We face a third major transition in science beyond the Pythagorean dream that "All is Number". We must give up deducing the diachronic evolution of the biosphere. All of physics, classical and quantum, however, apply to the analysis of existing life, a synchronic analysis. We begin to better understand the emergent creativity of an evolving biosphere. Thus, we are on the edge of inventing a physics-like new statistical mechanics of emergence.

Physics and Society,Biological Physics
Emergence of Quantum Mechanics from a Sub-Quantum Statistical Mechanics

Gerhard Groessing

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217979214501793

2013-04-12

Abstract:A research program within the scope of theories on "Emergent Quantum Mechanics" is presented, which has gained some momentum in recent years. Via the modeling of a quantum system as a non-equilibrium steady-state maintained by a permanent throughput of energy from the zero-point vacuum, the quantum is considered as an emergent system. We implement a specific "bouncer-walker" model in the context of an assumed sub-quantum statistical physics, in analogy to the results of experiments by Couder's group on a classical wave-particle duality. We can thus give an explanation of various quantum mechanical features and results on the basis of a "21st century classical physics", such as the appearance of Planck's constant, the Schrödinger equation, etc. An essential result is given by the proof that averaged particle trajectories' behaviors correspond to a specific type of anomalous diffusion termed "ballistic" diffusion on a sub-quantum level. It is further demonstrated both analytically and with the aid of computer simulations that our model provides explanations for various quantum effects such as double-slit or n-slit interference. We show the averaged trajectories emerging from our model to be identical to Bohmian trajectories, albeit without the need to invoke complex wave functions or any other quantum mechanical tool. Finally, the model provides new insights into the origins of entanglement, and, in particular, into the phenomenon of a "systemic" nonlocality.

Quantum Physics
Effective Dynamics of a Tracer Particle Interacting with an Ideal Bose Gas

D.-A. Deckert,J. Fröhlich,P. Pickl,A. Pizzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1210.0253

2012-11-27

Abstract:We study a system consisting of a heavy quantum particle, called tracer particle, coupled to an ideal gas of light Bose particles, the ratio of masses of the tracer particle and a gas particle being proportional to the gas density. All particles have non-relativistic kinematics. The tracer particle is driven by an external potential and couples to the gas particles through a pair potential. We compare the quantum dynamics of this system to an effective dynamics given by a Newtonian equation of motion for the tracer particle coupled to a classical wave equation for the Bose gas. We quantify the closeness of these two dynamics as the mean-field limit is approached (gas density $\to\infty$). Our estimates allow us to interchange the thermodynamic with the mean-field limit.

Mathematical Physics,Quantum Physics
Quantum trajectories and open many-body quantum systems

Andrew J. Daley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00018732.2014.933502

2014-05-27

Abstract:The study of open quantum systems has become increasingly important in the past years, as the ability to control quantum coherence on a single particle level has been developed in a wide variety of physical systems. In quantum optics, the study of open systems goes well beyond understanding the breakdown of quantum coherence. There, the coupling to the environment is sufficiently well understood that it can be manipulated to drive the system into desired quantum states, or to project the system onto known states via feedback in quantum measurements. Many mathematical frameworks have been developed to describe such systems, which for atomic, molecular, and optical (AMO) systems generally provide a very accurate description of the open quantum system on a microscopic level. In recent years, AMO systems including cold atomic and molecular gases and trapped ions have been applied heavily to the study of many-body physics, and it has become important to extend previous understanding of open system dynamics in single- and few-body systems to this many-body context. A key formalism that has already proven very useful in this context is the quantum trajectories technique. This was developed as a numerical tool for studying dynamics in open quantum systems, and falls within a broader framework of continuous measurement theory as a way to understand the dynamics of large classes of open quantum systems. We review the progress that has been made in studying open many-body systems in the AMO context, focussing on the application of ideas from quantum optics, and on the implementation and applications of quantum trajectories methods. Control over dissipative processes promises many further tools to prepare interesting and important states in strongly interacting systems, including the realisation of parameter regimes in quantum simulators that are inaccessible via current techniques.

Quantum Physics,Quantum Gases
Adiabatic and Nonadiabatic Dynamics with Interacting Quantum Trajectories

Federica Agostini,Lucien Dupuy,Francesco Talotta,David Lauvergnat,Bill Poirier,Yohann Scribano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2022-5glzl-v2

2024-02-06

Abstract:We present a quantum dynamics method based on the propagation of interacting quan- tum trajectories to describe both adiabatic and nonadiabatic processes within the same formalism. The idea originates from the work of Poirier [Chem. Phys. 370 4–14 (2010)] and Schiff and Poirier [J. Chem. Phys. 136 031102 (2012)] on quantum dynamics with- out wavefunctions. It consists in determining the quantum force arising in the Bohmian hydrodynamic formulation of quantum dynamics using only information about quan- tum trajectories. The particular time-dependent propagation scheme proposed here results in very stable dynamics. Its performance is discussed by applying the method to analytical potentials in the adiabatic regime, and by combining it with the exact factorization method in the nonadiabatic regime.

Chemistry
Trace anomaly and compact stars

Ignacio A. Reyes

2023-09-12

Abstract:A widespread assumption states that quantum effects of matter in curved spacetimes become relevant only when the inverse curvature radius approaches the Planck mass $m_{\text{P}}$. We challenge this view by showing that, relying solely on universal properties of QFTs at high energies, the trace anomaly becomes macroscopic instead at energy scales $ \left( m/m_{\text{P}} \right)^{\frac{1-\alpha}{2-\alpha}} m_{\text{P}}$, where $m\ll m_{\text{P}}$ and $\alpha<1$ are, respectively, the mass scale and exponent appearing in the matter equation of state at high energies. As an application, we consider compact stars close to their Buchdahl limit, and examine the propagation of scalar waves on the resulting backreacted geometries. At the aforementioned energy scale, the curvature becomes negative within a neighborhood of the the star's center, implying a qualitative change in the behavior of the associated spectrum of modes.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
Tracer dynamics in one dimensional gases of active or passive particles

Tirthankar Banerjee,Robert L. Jack,Michael E. Cates

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/ac4801

2022-02-10

Abstract:We consider one-dimensional systems comprising either active run-and-tumble particles (RTPs) or passive Brownian random walkers. These particles are either noninteracting or have hardcore exclusions. We study the dynamics of a single tracer particle embedded in such a system - this tracer may be either active or passive, with hardcore exclusion from environmental particles. In an active hardcore environment, both active and passive tracers show long-time subdiffusion: displacements scale as $t^{1/4}$ with a density-dependent prefactor that is independent of tracer type, and differs from the corresponding result for passive-in-passive subdiffusion. In an environment of noninteracting active particles, the passive-in-passive results are recovered at low densities for both active and passive tracers, but transient caging effects slow the tracer motion at higher densities, delaying the onset of any $t^{1/4}$ regime. For an active tracer in a passive environment, we find more complex outcomes, which depend on details of the dynamical discretization scheme. We interpret these results by studying the density distribution of environmental particles around the tracer. In particular, sticking of environment particles to the tracer cause it to move more slowly in noninteracting than in interacting active environments, while the anomalous behaviour of the active-in-passive cases stems from a `snowplough' effect whereby a large pile of diffusive environmental particles accumulates in front of a RTP tracer during a ballistic run.

Statistical Mechanics
Thermal quantum time-correlation functions from classical-like dynamics

Timothy J. H. Hele

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00268976.2017.1303548

2017-01-11

Abstract:Thermal quantum time-correlation functions are of fundamental importance in quantum dynamics, allowing experimentally-measurable properties such as reaction rates, diffusion constants and vibrational spectra to be computed from first principles. Since the exact quantum solution scales exponentially with system size, there has been considerable effort in formulating reliable linear-scaling methods involving exact quantum statistics and approximate quantum dynamics modelled with classical-like trajectories. Here we review recent progress in the field with the development of methods including Centroid Molecular Dynamics (CMD), Ring Polymer Molecular Dynamics (RPMD) and Thermostatted RPMD (TRPMD). We show how these methods have recently been obtained from `Matsubara dynamics', a form of semiclassical dynamics which conserves the quantum Boltzmann distribution. We also rederive t->0+ quantum transition-state theory (QTST) in the Matsubara dynamics formalism showing that Matsubara-TST, like RPMD-TST, is equivalent to QTST. We end by surveying areas for future progress.

Chemical Physics,Quantum Physics

Trace dynamics and its implications for my work of the last two decades

Book Review of Stephen L. Adler's, "Quantum theory as an emergent phenomenon."

A Dynamic Histories Interpretation of Quantum Theory

A link between static and dynamical perturbation theory

Expanding wave packets and the quantum to classical transition

The three and a half layers of dynamics : analog, digital, semi-digital, analog

Markovian dynamics for a quantum/classical system and quantum trajectories

On the geometrical hypotheses underlying wave functions and their emerging dynamics

Shape Dynamics and The Universe: Foundations and Implications

Understanding multiple timescales in quantum dissipative dynamics: Insights from quantum trajectories

Quantum Mechanics in a New Light

Disappearing Without a Trace: The Arrows of Time in Kent's Solution to the Lorentzian Quantum Reality Problem

Beyond the Newtonian Paradigm: A Statistical Mechanics of Emergence

Emergence of Quantum Mechanics from a Sub-Quantum Statistical Mechanics

Effective Dynamics of a Tracer Particle Interacting with an Ideal Bose Gas

Quantum trajectories and open many-body quantum systems

Adiabatic and Nonadiabatic Dynamics with Interacting Quantum Trajectories

Trace anomaly and compact stars

Tracer dynamics in one dimensional gases of active or passive particles

Thermal quantum time-correlation functions from classical-like dynamics