Search for the Migdal effect in liquid xenon with keV-level nuclear recoils

Jingke Xu,Duncan Adams,Brian Lenardo,Teal Pershing,Rachel Mannino,Ethan Bernard,James Kingston,Eli Mizrachi,Junsong Lin,Rouven Essig,Vladimir Mozin,Phil Kerr,Adam Bernstein,Mani Tripathi

2023-07-25

Abstract:The Migdal effect predicts that a nuclear recoil interaction can be accompanied by atomic ionization, allowing many dark matter direct detection experiments to gain sensitivity to sub-GeV masses. We report the first direct search for the Migdal effect for M- and L-shell electrons in liquid xenon using 7.0$\pm$1.6 keV nuclear recoils produced by tagged neutron scatters. Despite an observed background rate lower than that of expected signals in the region of interest, we do not observe a signal consistent with predictions. We discuss possible explanations, including inaccurate predictions for either the Migdal rate or the signal response in liquid xenon. We comment on the implications for direct dark-matter searches and future Migdal characterization efforts.

High Energy Physics - Experiment,Instrumentation and Detectors

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the Migdal effect associated with nuclear recoils in liquid xenon. Specifically, the researchers used (7.0 ± 1.6) keV nuclear recoils produced by tagged neutron scattering to directly search for the Migdal effect of M - shell and L - shell electrons in liquid xenon for the first time. Although the background rate observed in the region of interest was lower than the expected signal, the study did not find a signal consistent with the prediction. The paper discusses possible explanations, including inaccurate predictions of the Migdal rate or the signal response in liquid xenon, and comments on the significance of this result for direct dark matter detection and future Migdal effect characterization work.

### Introduction to the Migdal effect
The Migdal effect predicts that during the nuclear recoil interaction process, atoms may be ionized, allowing many direct dark matter detection experiments to increase their sensitivity to sub - GeV masses. This effect is particularly important for detecting low - mass dark matter because the energy transferred by these dark matter particles when scattering with nucleons or electrons is usually below the few - keV threshold of current experiments.

### Experimental design
The experiment used a two - phase xenon time - projection chamber (TPC). Electron recoils (ER) and nuclear recoils (NR) were distinguished by measuring the scintillation light (S1) and ionization signal (S2) during the scattering process. The neutron source used in the experiment was a mono - energetic 14.1 MeV neutron generated by a deuterium - tritium (DT) neutron generator. After being shielded by lead and borated water, the neutrons produced nuclear recoils in the TPC.

### Data analysis
Data analysis mainly focused on single - scattering (SS) neutron events at a fixed angle. Neutron candidate events were identified by the pulse - shape discrimination (PSD) technique of the liquid - scintillation detector (LS), and the S1 and S2 signals in the TPC were classified and mass - cut. Finally, through a two - dimensional maximum - likelihood fit of the S1 - S2 distribution, the researchers did not find a significant Migdal signal.

### Results and discussion
The best - fit Migdal signal rate was 16.3+21.7−16.3 times, far lower than the theoretically predicted 148.2 ± 16.3 times and consistent with a zero signal. This indicates that current calculations may overestimate the rate of Migdal ionization in liquid xenon, especially for M - shell and L - shell electrons. In addition, the researchers also considered the enhanced electron - ion recombination effect due to the proximity of ER and NR tracks, which may shift the Migdal signal to a region with lower experimental sensitivity.

### Future prospects
This experiment is the first to achieve a low - enough background level in any detection medium to study the Migdal effect caused by nuclear recoils, providing a path for future characterization work. If the enhanced recombination effect rather than the reduced Migdal interaction strength is the reason for the non - observed signal, then low - mass dark matter detection can still benefit from the Migdal effect because in such dark matter interactions, the NR component will be negligible. Future liquid - xenon Migdal experiments using lower - energy NRs will further reduce uncertainties and more clearly characterize this effect.