ESG Reputation Risk Matters: An Event Study Based on Social Media Data

Maxime L. D. Nicolas,Adrien Desroziers,Fabio Caccioli,Tomaso Aste

2023-07-21

Abstract:We investigate the response of shareholders to Environmental, Social, and Governance-related reputational risk (ESG-risk), focusing exclusively on the impact of social media. Using a dataset of 114 million tweets about firms listed on the S&P100 index between 2016 and 2022, we extract conversations discussing ESG matters. In an event study design, we define events as unusual spikes in message posting activity linked to ESG-risk, and we then examine the corresponding changes in the returns of related assets. By focusing on social media, we gain insight into public opinion and investor sentiment, an aspect not captured through ESG controversies news alone. To the best of our knowledge, our approach is the first to distinctly separate the reputational impact on social media from the physical costs associated with negative ESG controversy news. Our results show that the occurrence of an ESG-risk event leads to a statistically significant average reduction of 0.29% in abnormal returns. Furthermore, our study suggests this effect is predominantly driven by Social and Governance categories, along with the "Environmental Opportunities" subcategory. Our research highlights the considerable impact of social media on financial markets, particularly in shaping shareholders' perception of ESG reputation. We formulate several policy implications based on our findings.

General Economics,General Finance,Risk Management

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore shareholders' reactions to reputation risks related to Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) issues, with a particular focus on the role of social media. Specifically, the researchers utilized 114 million tweets about S&P 100 index constituent companies from 2016 to 2022, extracting discussions related to ESG matters. Through an event study design, they defined abnormal information release activities related to ESG risks and analyzed the impact of these events on related asset returns.

### Main Findings

1. **Overall Impact**: When ESG risk events occur, the abnormal return rate of stocks decreases by an average of approximately 0.29%, and this decline is statistically significant.
2. **Impact of Different Categories**:
- **Social and Governance Risks**: Social risk and governance risk events have a particularly significant impact on stock prices, leading to declines of 0.36% and 0.33%, respectively.
- **Environmental Risks**: Environmental risk events themselves do not have a significant impact on stock prices, but negative discussions in the "environmental opportunities" subcategory lead to a 0.34% decline in stock prices.
3. **Subcategory Analysis**:
- **Product Responsibility**: Product responsibility risk events lead to a 0.32% decline in stock prices.
- **Stakeholder Opposition**: Stakeholder opposition risk events lead to a 0.38% decline in stock prices.
- **Corporate Governance**: Corporate governance risk events lead to a 0.33% decline in stock prices.

### Methodology

1. **Data Sources**: The study used financial data, social media data, and news data, covering 114 million tweets about S&P 100 index constituent companies from 2016 to 2022.
2. **Text Analysis**: An extended ESG dictionary was constructed to distinguish between ESG-related and non-ESG-related conversations, and sentiment analysis was used to classify each tweet.
3. **Event Identification**: ESD identifiers (Rosner, 1983) were used to identify abnormal information release activities related to ESG risks.
4. **Event Study**: A market model was used to estimate the abnormal return rates of companies before and after the disclosure of ESG risk events, and to calculate the standardized average abnormal return rate (SAAR) and the standardized cumulative abnormal return rate (SCAAR).

### Conclusion

1. **Important Role of Social Media**: The study shows that social media plays an important role in shaping shareholders' perceptions of ESG reputation.
2. **Policy Recommendations**:
- **Enhanced Monitoring**: Policymakers and companies should enhance monitoring of ESG controversies on social media platforms.
- **Integration of ESG Factors**: It is recommended to integrate ESG factors into investment strategies to reduce potential ESG risk exposure.
- **Increase Investor Awareness**: Enhance investors' awareness of ESG risks and opportunities.

### Future Research Directions

1. **Industry and Regional Differences**: Explore the sensitivity of different industries and regions to specific ESG risks.
2. **Impact of Positive ESG Reputation**: Study the potential benefits of a positive ESG reputation on stock prices.