History and Problems of the Standard Model in Cosmology

Martin Lopez-Corredoira

2023-07-20

Abstract:Since the beginning of the 20th century, a continuous evolution and perfection of what we today call the standard cosmological model has been produced, although some authors like to distinguish separate periods within this evolution. A possible historical division of the development of cosmology into six periods is: (1) the initial period (1917-1927); (2) the period of development (1927-1945); (3) the period of consolidation (1945-1965); (4) the period of acceptance (1965-1980); (5) the period of enlargement (1980-1998); and (6) the period of high-precision experimental cosmology (1998-now). The last period started with a epistemological optimism that has declined with time, and the expression "crisis in cosmology" is now stubbornly reverberating in the media. The initial expectation of removing the pending minor problems arising from the increased accuracy of measurements has backfired: the higher the precision with which the standard model tries to fit the data, the greater the number of tensions that arise, the problems proliferating rather than diminishing.

History and Philosophy of Physics,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the historical development of the standard cosmological model and the problems it faces. Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects:

1. **Historical Stages of the Standard Cosmological Model**: The paper divides the development stages of cosmology according to different historical periods, from the early 20th century to the present. Each period has its specific achievements and challenges. For example:
- Initial Period (1917 - 1927): The main achievements during this period were the observation of a large number of galaxies outside the Milky Way and the proposal of Einstein's general theory of relativity.
- Development Period (1927 - 1945): The important discoveries during this period included the proposal of the Hubble - Lemaitre law, that is, the redshift of galaxies is linearly related to the distance, which is regarded as evidence of the expansion of the universe.
- Consolidation Period (1945 - 1965): The main contribution during this period was the "Big Bang" theory proposed by Gamow et al. and the prediction of the existence of cosmic background radiation.
- Acceptance Period (1965 - 1980): During this period, through more observational data, such as the discovery of the cosmic microwave background radiation, the position of the standard cosmological model was further consolidated.
- Expansion Period (1980 - 1998): During this period, the theory of cosmic inflation and the concept of dark matter were proposed to explain the flatness of the universe and the origin of large - scale structures.
- High - Precision Experimental Cosmology Period (1998 - present): During this period, through high - precision observational data, such as the redshift - distance relationship of supernovae Ia, the phenomenon of the accelerated expansion of the universe was further verified.

2. **Challenges Faced by the Standard Cosmological Model**: The paper discusses in detail the problems and challenges encountered by the standard cosmological model in each period, including but not limited to:
- **Homogeneity and Isotropy of the Universe**: Why does the universe appear to be uniform and isotropic on a large scale?
- **Uniform Distribution of Cosmic Background Radiation**: Why is the cosmic background radiation so uniform and its anisotropy is very small?
- **Flatness of the Universe**: Why is the geometric structure of the universe close to Euclidean geometry?
- **Origin of Large - Scale Structures**: How did the large - scale structures in the universe form?
- **Dark Matter and Dark Energy**: Do these hypothesized components really exist? How do they explain the observational data?
- **Cosmological Constant Problem**: Why does the observed value of the cosmological constant differ so much from the theoretical prediction?
- **Early Nucleosynthesis in the Universe**: The difference between the abundance of light elements and the theoretical prediction, especially the abundance problem of lithium - 7.
- **Anomalies in Cosmic Background Radiation**: Some abnormal phenomena in the cosmic background radiation, such as the lack of low - multipole signals and the alignment of the quadrupole moment and the octupole moment, are inconsistent with the standard model.

3. **Criticisms of the Standard Cosmological Model**: The paper also discusses some scientists' criticisms of the standard cosmological model, including doubts about concepts such as dark matter, dark energy, and cosmic inflation, as well as reflections on the sociological and philosophical aspects of these theories.

In short, this paper aims to comprehensively review the historical development of the standard cosmological model, and at the same time point out the problems and challenges it faces at different stages, providing references and inspiration for future research.