Has China caught up to the US in AI research? An exploration of mimetic isomorphism as a model for late industrializers

Chao Min,Yi Zhao,Yi Bu,Ying Ding,Caroline S. Wagner

2023-07-12

Abstract:Artificial Intelligence (AI), a cornerstone of 21st-century technology, has seen remarkable growth in China. In this paper, we examine China's AI development process, demonstrating that it is characterized by rapid learning and differentiation, surpassing the export-oriented growth propelled by Foreign Direct Investment seen in earlier Asian industrializers. Our data indicates that China currently leads the USA in the volume of AI-related research papers. However, when we delve into the quality of these papers based on specific metrics, the USA retains a slight edge. Nevertheless, the pace and scale of China's AI development remain noteworthy. We attribute China's accelerated AI progress to several factors, including global trends favoring open access to algorithms and research papers, contributions from China's broad diaspora and returnees, and relatively lax data protection policies. In the vein of our research, we have developed a novel measure for gauging China's imitation of US research. Our analysis shows that by 2018, the time lag between China and the USA in addressing AI research topics had evaporated. This finding suggests that China has effectively bridged a significant knowledge gap and could potentially be setting out on an independent research trajectory. While this study compares China and the USA exclusively, it's important to note that research collaborations between these two nations have resulted in more highly cited work than those produced by either country independently. This underscores the power of international cooperation in driving scientific progress in AI.

Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore whether China has caught up with the United States in the field of artificial intelligence (AI) research. Specifically, by testing and analyzing the rapid development process of China in the AI field, the paper examines the effectiveness of mimetic isomorphism as a catch - up model for late - industrializing countries. The paper points out that although China has surpassed the United States in the number of AI papers, it still lags behind the United States in quality indicators; however, China's AI development is still impressive. The paper further analyzes the phenomenon that the time gap between China and the United States in AI research disappeared in 2018, which indicates that China may have closed the significant gap with the United States and may be moving towards an independent development trajectory. In addition, the paper also compares the impact of cooperation and individual research between China and the United States in the AI field, and the impact of this on the quality of their respective research.

The paper evaluates China's catch - up situation in the AI research field through the following aspects:

1. **Research stock**: Measure the total research output produced by a country in a scientific field to examine the comparison between China, starting from a low point, and the United States in the AI research field over time.
2. **Incremental research**: Depict the growth trajectories of China and the United States in the AI field in a dynamic time frame, check whether one side imitates the actions of the pioneer / incumbent, and test whether the release time of policy statements coincides with the growth of research.
3. **Scientific cooperation structure**: Evaluate the importance of the scientific cooperation structure for national capacity development, and test whether China imitates the United States in choosing its own partners.
4. **Research quality**: Evaluate using performance indicators of the two countries in the AI field, including the proportion of highly - cited papers (such as PP - top1%), the number of papers published in top - level conferences and journals, two - year and five - year citation times, etc.
5. **Research content**: Directly assess the similarity in AI research content between China and the United States. If the content of AI publications produced by China as a latecomer is getting closer and closer to that of the United States, it can be reasonably inferred that mimetic isomorphism is at work.

Through these analyses, the paper attempts to answer the questions of whether and how China has caught up with or surpassed the United States in the AI research field, and at the same time explore whether China's development model conforms to the traditional catch - up model of late - industrializing countries or has formed its own unique rapid imitation and development model.