Impact of Committed Minorities: Unveiling Critical Mass of Cooperation in the Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma Game

Zhixue He,Chen Shen,Lei Shi,Jun Tanimoto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.6.013062

2023-07-17

Abstract:The critical mass effect is a prevailing topic in the study of complex systems. Recent research has shown that a minority of zealots can effectively drive widespread cooperation in social dilemma games. However, achieving a critical mass of cooperation in the prisoner's dilemma requires stricter conditions. The underlying mechanism behind this effect remains unclear, particularly in the context of repeated interactions. This paper aims to investigate the influence of a committed minority on cooperation in the Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma game, a widely studied model of repeated interactions between individuals facing a social dilemma. In contrast to previous findings, we identify tipping points for both well-mixed and structured populations. Our findings demonstrate that a committed minority of unconditional cooperators can induce full cooperation under weak imitation conditions. Conversely, a committed minority of conditional cooperators, who often employ Tit-for-Tat or extortion strategies, can promote widespread cooperation under strong imitation conditions. These results hold true across various network topologies and imitation rules, suggesting that critical mass effects may be a universal principle in social dilemma games. Additionally, we discover that an excessive density of committed conditional cooperators can hinder cooperation in structured populations. This research advances our understanding of the role of committed minorities in shaping social behavior and provides valuable insights into cooperation dynamics.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore how a small number of committed cooperators (i.e., "committed individuals") influence the emergence of cooperative behavior in the iterative Prisoner's Dilemma game. Specifically, the research aims to reveal whether these committed individuals can trigger the critical - mass effect of cooperation under different conditions (such as selection intensity, network topology, or update rules). The paper explores this issue by analyzing three typical strategies: unconditional cooperation, unconditional defection, and extortion strategies, and considering the influence of committed individuals adopting these strategies. The research results show that even in a structured population, a small number of committed individuals can effectively promote extensive cooperative behavior. Especially under strong selection conditions, committed extortionists have a particularly significant role in promoting cooperation. In addition, the study also finds that when the density of committed extortionists is too high, it will, on the contrary, hinder the emergence of cooperative behavior. These findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the role of committed minorities in social dilemma games and provide valuable insights into the dynamics of cooperation.