Quantal Response Equilibrium with a Continuum of Types: Characterization and Nonparametric Identification

Evan Friedman,Duarte Gonçalves

2023-07-16

Abstract:Quantal response equilibrium (QRE), a statistical generalization of Nash equilibrium, is a standard benchmark in the analysis of experimental data. Despite its influence, nonparametric characterizations and tests of QRE are unavailable beyond the case of finite games. We address this gap by completely characterizing the set of QRE in a class of binary-action games with a continuum of types. Our characterization provides sharp predictions in settings such as global games, volunteer's dilemma, and the compromise game. Further, we leverage our results to develop nonparametric tests of QRE. As an empirical application, we revisit the experimental data from Carrillo and Palfrey (2009) on the compromise game.

Theoretical Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are: in the binary - action games with continuous types, fully characterize the set of Quantal Response Equilibrium (QRE), and develop non - parametric test methods to verify QRE. Specifically:

1. **Complete Characterization of QRE**:
- The author focuses on a class of infinite games, that is, games with binary actions and continuous types. In such games, QRE is a function that maps types to the probabilities of taking specific actions.
- By assuming the monotonicity condition of the payoff function, the author proves that any QRE is a continuous and strictly monotonic function, and there exists a unique type that randomly chooses between the two actions indifferently.
- The specific mathematical expression is as follows:
\[
\sigma \text{ is QRE} \iff \begin{cases}
\sigma \text{ is continuous and strictly monotonically increasing} \\
\sigma \in (0, 1) \\
\exists \tilde{x} \in (0, 1) \text{ such that } \sigma(\tilde{x}) = \frac{1}{2} \text{ and } \Delta \bar{u}_{\tilde{x}}(\sigma) = 0
\end{cases}
\]
- Here, \(\Delta \bar{u}_x(\sigma)=\bar{u}_1(x, \sigma)-\bar{u}_0(x, \sigma)\) represents the expected utility difference between taking action 1 and 0 for type \(x\).

2. **Non - parametric Test Methods**:
- The author uses the above results to develop a non - parametric method to test whether the data can be explained by QRE.
- The test method is mainly based on two conditions:
1. The selection probability is monotonic with respect to the type.
2. The types of uniform randomization are indifferent between the two actions.

3. **Application Examples**:
- The author applies these results to several classic application scenarios, including the volunteer's dilemma, global games, and compromise games.
- By re - analyzing the experimental data of Carrillo and Palfrey (2009) on the compromise game, the author finds that although the monotonicity cannot be rejected, there is a significant difference in the expected utility between the two actions for the types of uniform randomization, which violates the second condition of QRE.

In conclusion, this paper expands the application range of QRE in infinite games by providing a complete characterization of QRE and non - parametric test methods, and provides new tools for empirical research.