Comparative study of variations in quantum approximate optimization algorithms for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Wenyang Qian,Robert A. M. Basili,Mary Eshaghian-Wilner,Ashfaq Khokhar,Glenn Luecke,James P. Vary

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e25081238

2023-07-14

Abstract:The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is one of the most often-used NP-Hard problems in computer science to study the effectiveness of computing models and hardware platforms. In this regard, it is also heavily used as a vehicle to study the feasibility of the quantum computing paradigm for this class of problems. In this paper, we tackle the TSP using the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) approach by formulating it as an optimization problem. By adopting an improved qubit encoding strategy and a layerwise learning optimization protocol, we present numerical results obtained from the gate-based digital quantum simulator, specifically targeting TSP instances with 3, 4, and 5 cities. We focus on the evaluations of three distinctive QAOA mixer designs, considering their performances in terms of numerical accuracy and optimization cost. Notably, we find a well-balanced QAOA mixer design exhibits more promising potential for gate-based simulators and realistic quantum devices in the long run, an observation further supported by our noise model simulations. Furthermore, we investigate the sensitivity of the simulations to the TSP graph. Overall, our simulation results show the digital quantum simulation of problem-inspired ansatz is a successful candidate for finding optimal TSP solutions.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

This paper primarily explores how to use the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) to solve the Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP). Specifically:

1. **Problem Background**:
- TSP is one of the commonly used NP-hard problems in computer science, used to study the effectiveness of computational models and hardware platforms.
- In recent years, with the advancement of quantum technology, various quantum computing methods have been applied to solve TSP, including the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA).

2. **Research Objectives**:
- By representing TSP as an optimization problem and adopting an improved qubit encoding strategy and layered learning optimization protocol, the paper demonstrates numerical results on a gate-based digital quantum simulator.
- It compares the performance of three different QAOA mixer designs in terms of numerical accuracy and optimization cost.

3. **Main Contributions**:
- The paper investigates the impact of different QAOA mixer designs on TSP solutions, particularly in cases involving 3, 4, and 5 cities.
- It explores the effect of noise models on simulation results and evaluates the sensitivity of different TSP graphs to the simulations.
- It identifies a well-balanced QAOA mixer design with potential for long-term use on gate-based simulators and real quantum devices.

4. **Experimental Methods**:
- Experiments were conducted using Qiskit on a digital quantum simulator, comparing the performance of three different mixer designs (X mixer, XY mixer, and row swap mixer).
- Through multiple simulation experiments, the results of the lowest converged expected values were reported, using the Approximation Ratio (AR) as an evaluation metric.

In summary, this paper aims to solve TSP using the QAOA method and compares the effectiveness and resource consumption of different mixer designs, providing valuable references for future quantum computing in solving complex optimization problems.