Advertiser Learning in Direct Advertising Markets

Carl F. Mela,Jason M.T. Roos,Tulio Sousa
2024-05-01
Abstract:Direct buy advertisers procure advertising inventory at fixed rates from publishers and ad networks. Such advertisers face the complex task of choosing ads amongst myriad new publisher sites. We offer evidence that advertisers do not excel at making these choices. Instead, they try many sites before settling on a favored set, consistent with advertiser learning. We subsequently model advertiser demand for publisher inventory wherein advertisers learn about advertising efficacy across publishers' sites. Results suggest that advertisers spend considerable resources advertising on sites they eventually abandon--in part because their prior beliefs about advertising efficacy on those sites are too optimistic. The median advertiser's expected CTR at a new site is 0.23%, five times higher than the true median CTR of 0.045%. We consider how an ad network's pooling of advertiser information remediates this problem. As ads with similar visual elements garner similar CTRs, the network's pooling of information enables advertisers to better predict ad performance at new sites. Counterfactual analyses indicate that gains from pooling advertiser information are substantial: over six months, we estimate a median advertiser welfare gain of \$2,756 (a 15.5% increase) and a median publisher revenue gain of \$9,618 (a 63.9% increase).
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper examines the issue of how advertisers select ad slots among numerous publisher websites in the online direct purchase advertising market. The study found that advertisers often overestimate the performance of ads on new websites initially, and only after trying multiple websites do they determine their preferred publishers. The paper establishes a learning model for advertisers' demand for publisher inventory, in which advertisers gradually understand the performance of ads on different websites. The results show that advertisers initially have a high expectation for click-through rate (CTR), with an actual median CTR of 0.045%, compared to their expected rate of 0.23%. The paper also proposes that aggregating advertiser information through ad networks can improve this problem, as ads with similar visual elements usually have similar CTRs. Sharing information can help advertisers predict the performance of ads on new websites more accurately. Through counterfactual analysis of information sharing, the study estimates that the average welfare of advertisers can be increased by 15.5%, while publisher revenue can increase by an average of 63.9%. In addition, the paper emphasizes that economic theories related to advertising performance learning often assume that advertisers have prior knowledge of ad value, but in reality, advertisers need to learn before making purchases. The paper proposes a method to enhance advertisers' expectations of ad performance on new websites using machine learning image recognition technology. Through this approach, ad networks can improve advertisers' decision-making efficiency and increase overall welfare.