Emergent quantum phase transition of a Josephson junction coupled to a high-impedance multimode resonator

Luca Giacomelli,Cristiano Ciuti

2023-12-28

Abstract:The physics of a single Josephson junction coupled to a resistive environment is a long-standing fundamental problem at the center of an intense debate, strongly revived by the advent of superconducting platforms with high-impedance multimode resonators. Here we investigate the emergent criticality of a junction coupled to a multimode resonator when the number of modes is increased. We demonstrate how the multimode environment renormalizes the Josephson and capacitive energies of the junction so that in the thermodynamic limit the charging energy dominates when the impedance is larger than the resistance quantum and is negligible otherwise, independently from the bare ratio between the two energy scales and the compact or extended nature of the phase of the junction. Via exact diagonalization, we find that the transition surprisingly stems from a level anticrossing involving not the ground state, but the first excited state, whose energy gap vanishes in the thermodynamic limit. We clarify the nature of the two phases by pointing at a different behaviour of the ground and excited states and we show that at the transition point the spectrum displays universality not only at low frequencies. In agreement with recent experiments, we reveal striking spectral signatures of the phase transition.

Quantum Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether a quantum phase transition will occur when a Josephson junction is coupled with a high - impedance multimode resonator, and the specific characteristics of such a phase transition. Specifically, the research focuses on the following points:

1. **Which terms in the circuit Hamiltonian become unimportant in the thermodynamic limit?**
2. **Does a phase transition actually occur? How can the so - called insulating state be detected?**
3. **Does the compactness or extensibility of the Josephson junction phase play a role?**
4. **Is the phase transition independent of the ratio of Josephson energy \(E_J\) and charging energy \(E_C\)?**

### Research Background

The problem of a Josephson junction coupled with a resistive environment is a long - standing fundamental problem. Especially after the emergence of high - impedance multimode resonators on superconducting platforms, this problem has once again attracted wide attention. Classical theory predicts that when the resistance \(R\) is less than the resistance quantum \(R_q=\frac{h}{2e^2}\), the Josephson junction exhibits superconducting behavior (phase localization), and when \(R > R_q\), it exhibits insulating behavior (phase delocalization). However, experimental results are controversial regarding this, and some experimental reports claim that no insulating behavior has been observed.

### Research Methods

The author explores the emergent properties of the phase transition when the free spectral range (mode frequency spacing) approaches zero by analyzing the system of a Josephson junction coupled with a multimode transmission line resonator. The research uses analytical methods and numerically exact diagonalization techniques to conduct a detailed analysis of finite - size systems.

### Main Findings

1. **Emergence of the Phase Transition**:
- When the free spectral range approaches zero, the system undergoes a phase transition at \(R_q/Z = 1\), where \(Z\) is the characteristic impedance of the transmission line.
- At the phase transition point, the energy spectrum of the system exhibits universality, and this universality exists not only at low frequencies but also is evident at high frequencies.

2. **Characteristics of the Phase Transition**:
- The phase transition is mainly caused by the level anti - crossing of the first excited state, not the ground state.
- At the phase transition point, the behaviors of the ground state and the excited state are different, and the ground state is always located at the quasi - charge \(\nu = 0\).
- For \(R_q/Z < 1\), the charging energy is dominant, showing the so - called insulating behavior; for \(R_q/Z > 1\), the charging energy can be ignored, showing superconducting behavior.

3. **Spectroscopic Characteristics**:
- The dispersion relation of the high - frequency mode changes significantly near the phase transition point, which is consistent with experimental observations.
- By calculating the photon spectral function, the energy - spectrum characteristics near the phase transition point are further verified.

### Conclusion

Through analytical methods and numerically exact diagonalization, the author reveals the emergent properties of the phase transition in the system of a Josephson junction coupled with a high - impedance multimode transmission line. The research confirms the controversial Schmid - Bulgadaev phase transition and shows the unconventional nature and unique spectroscopic characteristics of this phase transition. These findings are helpful for understanding the quantum phase - transition behavior of Josephson junctions in complex environments.