Explaining the unexplainable: leveraging extremal dependence to characterize the 2021 Pacific Northwest heatwave

Likun Zhang,Mark D. Risser,Michael F. Wehner,Travis A. O'Brien

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13253-024-00636-8

2023-07-07

Abstract:In late June, 2021, a devastating heatwave affected the US Pacific Northwest and western Canada, breaking numerous all-time temperature records by large margins and directly causing hundreds of fatalities. The observed 2021 daily maximum temperature across much of the U.S. Pacific Northwest exceeded upper bound estimates obtained from single-station temperature records even after accounting for anthropogenic climate change, meaning that the event could not have been predicted under standard univariate extreme value analysis assumptions. In this work, we utilize a flexible spatial extremes model that considers all stations across the Pacific Northwest domain and accounts for the fact that many stations simultaneously experience extreme temperatures. Our analysis incorporates the effects of anthropogenic forcing and natural climate variability in order to better characterize time-varying changes in the distribution of daily temperature extremes. We show that greenhouse gas forcing, drought conditions and large-scale atmospheric modes of variability all have significant impact on summertime maximum temperatures in this region. Our model represents a significant improvement over corresponding single-station analysis, and our posterior medians of the upper bounds are able to anticipate more than 96% of the observed 2021 high station temperatures after properly accounting for extremal dependence.

Applications,Methodology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: how to better explain and predict the extreme temperatures of the 2021 Pacific Northwest (PNW) heatwave in the United States, especially those anomalously high temperatures that exceed the predictive range of traditional single-station extreme value analysis. Specifically, the paper aims to improve the statistical modeling of extreme temperature distributions and their changes by considering spatial coherence and multi-station data, in order to more accurately assess the impact of human activities and natural climate variability on such extreme events.

### Main Research Objectives:
1. **Explain the statistical challenges of extreme temperatures**: Traditional single-station extreme value analysis methods failed to predict the 2021 PNW heatwave because the estimated upper temperature limits were lower than the actual observed maximum temperatures. The paper attempts to address this issue by introducing more flexible spatial extreme value models.
2. **Quantify the impact of human activities and natural variability**: Through statistical models, the paper aims to better understand the influence of human activities (such as greenhouse gas emissions) and natural climate variability (such as El Niño phenomena, drought conditions, etc.) on extreme temperatures.
3. **Improve predictive capability**: By improving statistical models, the paper hopes to more accurately predict the probability and severity of similar future events before they occur.

### Methodological Innovations:
1. **Non-stationary marginal generalized extreme value analysis**: Introduce multiple covariates (such as greenhouse gas forcing, drought index, El Niño index, etc.) to describe the spatiotemporal variations of temperature extremes.
2. **Consider spatial dependence in climatology**: Model the spatial variations of GEV coefficients using thin plate splines and topographical features to ensure the model captures the correlations between different locations.
3. **Consider the spatial coherence of individual events**: Use a Gaussian scale mixture model to describe the simultaneous impact of a single heatwave event at multiple stations, thereby more accurately capturing the spatial dependence of extreme events.

### Conclusion:
Through these methodological innovations, the paper successfully improves the explanatory and predictive capabilities for the 2021 PNW heatwave event, better quantifying the impact of human activities and natural climate variability on extreme temperatures. This provides important scientific evidence for future climate risk assessments and response strategies.