Subsets of free groups with distinct differences

Simon R. Blackburn,Emma Smith,Luke Stewart
2023-07-07
Abstract:Let $F_n$ be a free group of rank $n$, with free generating set $X$. A subset $D$ of $F_n$ is a \emph{Distinct Difference Configuration} if the differences $g^{-1}h$ are distinct, where $g$ and $h$ range over all (ordered) pairs of distinct elements of $D$. The subset $D$ has diameter at most $d$ if these differences all have length at most $d$. When $n$ is fixed and $d$ is large, the paper shows that the largest distinct difference configuration in $F_n$ of diameter at most $d$ has size approximately $(2n-1)^{d/3}$.
Group Theory,Combinatorics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in a free group, find the maximum size of subsets with a fixed diameter, where the differences between pairs of elements in these subsets are unique. Specifically, the author studied the maximum cardinality \(m(n, d)\) of subsets with distinct difference configurations (DDC) in the free group \(F_n\), where \(d\) is the diameter of the subset. ### Problem Background - **Free Group**: The free group \(F_n\) is a group freely generated by a set of generators \(X\). - **Distinct Difference Configuration (DDC)**: A subset \(D\subseteq F_n\) is called a DDC if the differences \(g^{-1}h\) of all different pairs of elements \((g, h)\in D\times D\) are unique. - **Diameter**: The diameter of a subset \(D\) is defined as the maximum distance between any two elements in \(D\). Here, the distance is the length of the shortest path defined on the Cayley graph of the group. ### Research Objectives The main objective of the paper is to determine the asymptotic behavior of the size \(m(n, d)\) of the maximum DDC as \(d\rightarrow\infty\) when \(n\) is fixed. Specifically, the author proved the following theorem: \[ m(n, d)=(2n - 1)^{d/3}+O(\log d) \] ### Main Contributions 1. **Upper Bound**: By combinatorial and geometric methods, the author proved that \(m(n, d)\leq c(2n - 1)^{d/3}\), where \(c\) is a constant independent of \(d\) but depending on \(n\). 2. **Lower Bound**: By probabilistic methods, the author proved that there exists a DDC whose size is at least \((2n - 1)^{d/3}+O(\log d)\). ### Application Background This research is not only of great significance in the field of pure mathematics, but also has potential applications in fields such as cryptography and wireless sensor networks. For example, in wireless sensor networks, nodes can be arranged into a regular tree structure, and the key distribution problem in this structure can be transformed into a DDC problem in a free group. ### Conclusion Through strict mathematical derivations, the paper provides an accurate estimate of the size of DDC in a free group, fills this gap in the field, and provides a theoretical basis for further research on other types of groups and other related problems.