$J/ψ$ Pair Hadroproduction at Next-to-Leading Order in Nonrelativistic-QCD at CMS

Liping Sun

2023-07-06

Abstract:We perform a complete study on the $J/\psi$ pair hadroproduction at next-to-leading order (NLO) in the nonrelativstic-QCD (NRQCD) framework with the pair of $c\bar{c}$ either in ${}^{3}S_1^{[1]}$ or ${}^{1}S_0^{[8]}$ fock state. It is found that the ${}^{1}S_0^{[8]}$ channel contribution at NLO is essential. Our results indicate that for the CMS, the NRQCD predictions can not describe the experimental data at all, and the total cross section predicted by NRQCD is smaller than the experimental data by an order of magnitude. So new mechanisms are needed to understand the CMS data for $J/\psi$ pair production.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to carry out accurate theoretical calculations for the hadronic production process of J/ψ meson pairs within the framework of Nonrelativistic Quantum Chromodynamics (NRQCD), especially to calculate its contribution at the Next - to - Leading Order (NLO). Specifically, the authors focus on the total cross - section, transverse momentum distribution, invariant mass distribution, and rapidity difference distribution of J/ψ meson pair production under the CMS experimental conditions, and compare them with the experimental data.

### Research Background
- **Research Motivation**: The production of J/ψ meson pairs is an important research object in heavy quarkonium physics. By studying this process, the validity of the NRQCD factorization hypothesis can be verified and understood, especially in multi - quarkonium production.
- **Existing Research**: Previous research mainly focused on the production of a single J/ψ meson, while the production of multi - quarkonium provides supplementary information, which is helpful for a more comprehensive understanding of the quarkonium production mechanism.

### Main Problems
- **Differences between Theory and Experiment**: The existing NRQCD predictions (including the leading order and the next - to - leading order) are significantly different from the CMS experimental data, especially in the high - transverse - momentum region. Specifically, the total cross - section predicted by the theory is one order of magnitude smaller than the experimental data.
- **Need for New Mechanisms**: In order to better explain the experimental data, it may be necessary to introduce new physical mechanisms, such as Double Parton Scattering (DPS) or other models.

### Research Methods
- **Calculation Framework**: Use the NRQCD factorization framework to decompose the production process of J/ψ meson pairs into the product of Short - Distance Coefficients (SDCs) and Long - Distance Matrix Elements (LDMEs).
- **Calculation Content**: The NLO contributions of J/ψ meson pairs in the 3S[1]_1 and 1S[8]_0 states are calculated in detail, including virtual part corrections, soft - radiation corrections, and hard - radiation corrections.

### Main Findings
- **Importance of Next - to - Leading Order**: The NLO correction is very important for the production of J/ψ meson pairs, especially in the high - transverse - momentum region, which can significantly reduce the theoretical uncertainty.
- **Inconsistency between Theory and Experiment**: Although the NLO correction is considered, the NRQCD prediction still cannot describe the CMS experimental data, especially in terms of the total cross - section, transverse momentum distribution, invariant mass distribution, and rapidity difference distribution. The theoretical prediction value is one order of magnitude smaller than the experimental data.
- **Need for New Mechanisms**: These results indicate that the NRQCD framework relying solely on the single - parton - scattering mechanism is not sufficient to explain the experimental data, and other mechanisms, such as DPS or the Color Evaporation Model (CEM), need to be introduced.

### Conclusions
- **Main Conclusion**: Although the NRQCD NLO calculation improves the theoretical accuracy, it still cannot explain the CMS experimental data. This implies that there may be other important physical mechanisms in the production process of J/ψ meson pairs.
- **Future Work**: The authors plan to further study the NLO contributions of other states (such as 3S[8]_1 and 3P[8]_J) and explore the influence of DPS and other models.

Through these studies, the authors hope to provide more comprehensive theoretical support for understanding the production mechanism of heavy quarkonium.