The Quantum Advantage in Binary Teams and the Coordination Dilemma: Part II

Shashank A. Deshpande,Ankur A. Kulkarni
2023-07-04
Abstract:In our previous work, we have shown that the use of a quantum architecture in decentralised control allows access to a larger space of control strategies beyond what is classically implementable through common randomness, and can lead to an improvement in the cost -- a phenomenon we called the quantum advantage. In the previous part of this two part series, we showed, however, that not all decision problems admit such an advantage. We identified a decision-theoretic property of the cost called the `coordination dilemma' as a necessary condition for the quantum advantage to manifest. In this article, we investigate the impact on the quantum advantage of a scalar parameter that captures the extent of the coordination dilemma. We show that this parameter can be bounded within an open interval for the quantum advantage to exist, and for some classes, we precisely identify this range of values. This range is found to be determined by the information of the agents.
Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the advantages of quantum architectures in binary teams and their impact on the coordination dilemma. Specifically: 1. **Existence conditions of quantum advantage**: - The author's previous research has shown that using a quantum architecture can access a larger strategy space in decentralized control than what can be achieved by classical methods through common randomness, and may reduce costs. This phenomenon is called "quantum advantage". - However, not all decision - making problems have this advantage. This paper further explores the factors that affect the existence of quantum advantage, in particular, introducing a scalar parameter \(\chi\) to quantify the degree of the coordination dilemma. 2. **Quantification of the coordination dilemma**: - The coordination dilemma refers to the situation in which agents need a high degree of coordination to reach the optimal solution in some decision - making problems. This paper defines a scalar parameter \(\chi\) to capture the degree of this dilemma. - The author studies the value range of \(\chi\) to determine which problem instances can benefit from quantum strategies and thus achieve quantum advantage. 3. **Implementation of quantum strategies**: - The author proves that in some problem classes, all quantum strategies can be implemented through an entangled system with one qubit for each decision - maker. This makes the parameterization of quantum strategies possible. - Through the parameterization method, the author further optimizes the cost function of quantum strategies, thereby finding the optimal quantum strategy. 4. **Analysis of specific problem classes**: - This paper focuses particularly on two types of problems: the CAC class and the 1/2 - CAC class. For these two types of problems, the author determines the value range of \(\chi\) respectively, and the problem instances within these ranges can benefit from quantum resources. - The author also finds that for the 1/2 - CAC class problems, the \(\chi\) range in which there is a quantum advantage is a narrower interval, indicating that the impact of the severity of the coordination dilemma on the quantum advantage varies in different problem classes. ### Main contributions - **Theoretical framework**: This paper establishes a decision - theory framework for analyzing the performance of quantum advantage in static teams. - **Parameterization method**: By parameterizing quantum strategies, the optimization problem is simplified, making it possible to find the optimal quantum strategy. - **Specific results**: The value ranges of \(\chi\) in which there is a quantum advantage in the CAC and 1/2 - CAC class problems are determined, providing a theoretical basis for practical applications. ### Conclusion Through strict mathematical derivations and the parameterization method, this paper deeply explores the existence conditions of quantum advantage in binary teams and its relationship with the coordination dilemma. The research results not only enrich the theoretical basis of quantum computing in the field of decentralized control but also provide guidance for practical applications.