Sensors and Systems for Monitoring Mental Fatigue: A systematic review

Prabin Sharma,Joanna C. Justus,Megha Thapa,Govinda R. Poudel
2023-09-11
Abstract:Mental fatigue is a leading cause of motor vehicle accidents, medical errors, loss of workplace productivity, and student disengagements in e-learning environment. Development of sensors and systems that can reliably track mental fatigue can prevent accidents, reduce errors, and help increase workplace productivity. This review provides a critical summary of theoretical models of mental fatigue, a description of key enabling sensor technologies, and a systematic review of recent studies using biosensor-based systems for tracking mental fatigue in humans. We conducted a systematic search and review of recent literature which focused on detection and tracking of mental fatigue in humans. The search yielded 57 studies (N=1082), majority of which used electroencephalography (EEG) based sensors for tracking mental fatigue. We found that EEG-based sensors can provide a moderate to good sensitivity for fatigue detection. Notably, we found no incremental benefit of using high-density EEG sensors for application in mental fatigue detection. Given the findings, we provide a critical discussion on the integration of wearable EEG and ambient sensors in the context of achieving real-world monitoring. Future work required to advance and adapt the technologies toward widespread deployment of wearable sensors and systems for fatigue monitoring in semi-autonomous and autonomous industries is examined.
Human-Computer Interaction,Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of how to monitor mental fatigue through reliable sensors and systems to prevent accidents, reduce errors, and improve work efficiency. Specifically, the paper aims to review existing theoretical models, key sensing technologies, and biosensors used in recent studies, exploring the effectiveness of these technologies in practical applications and future development directions. ### Main Issues: 1. **Impact of Mental Fatigue**: Mental fatigue is one of the main causes of traffic accidents, medical errors, decreased workplace productivity, and disengagement among online learning students. 2. **Limitations of Existing Technologies**: Current monitoring technologies need further improvement to achieve reliable, user-friendly, and safe real-time monitoring. 3. **Future Development Directions**: How to apply existing sensing technologies and systems to semi-automated and fully automated industries to revolutionize fatigue monitoring practices. ### Specific Objectives: - **Review Theoretical Models**: Summarize and evaluate existing theoretical models of mental fatigue. - **Explore Key Sensing Technologies**: Analyze key sensor technologies used to monitor mental fatigue, particularly electroencephalogram (EEG) sensors. - **Systematic Evaluation of Research**: Conduct a systematic evaluation of recent studies using biosensors to monitor human mental fatigue. - **Propose Future Research Directions**: Discuss the focus of future research and technological development, especially the feasibility in practical applications. ### Methods: - **Literature Search**: Conduct a systematic search using APA PsycINFO and Medline Complete databases without date restrictions. - **Screening Criteria**: Exclude studies that do not meet the requirements, such as clinical samples, animal samples, dissertations, and book chapters. - **Data Extraction**: Extract descriptive statistics, measurement methods, experimental stimuli, prediction methods, and accuracy data from each selected paper. ### Results: - **Study Characteristics**: A total of 57 studies were included, mainly using EEG sensors, with most studies employing driving simulators as experimental stimuli. - **Sensor Performance**: EEG sensors showed moderate to good sensitivity in detecting mental fatigue, with high-density EEG sensors demonstrating significant advantages. - **Prediction Methods**: Classification and neural network methods had higher accuracy, but the differences between different methods were not statistically significant. ### Discussion: - **Impact of Sensor Quantity**: Using more EEG channels does not necessarily improve prediction accuracy, which may be related to the distribution characteristics of brain activity. - **Challenges in Practical Applications**: Future research should focus on real driving scenarios, especially for professions prone to fatigue, such as truck drivers and taxi drivers. - **Technological Development Trends**: Portable and comfortable EEG devices and advanced algorithms based on neural networks are expected to be widely used in the future. ### Conclusion: The paper provides important insights into mental fatigue monitoring through a systematic review of existing research and points out future research and technological development directions. These findings help promote the development and application of more reliable and practical mental fatigue monitoring systems.