Can Symmetric Tilt Grain Boundaries Represent Polycrystals?

Malik Wagih,Christopher A. Schuh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2023.115716

2023-08-27

Abstract:Grain boundaries control a wide variety of bulk properties in polycrystalline materials, so simulation methods like density functional theory are routinely used to study their structure-property relationships. A standard practice for such simulations is to use compact, high-symmetry (coincident site lattice) boundaries as representatives of the much more complex polycrystalline grain boundaries. In this letter, we question this practice by quantitatively comparing the spectra of atomic sites and properties amongst grain boundaries. We show, using solute segregation as an example property, that highly symmetric tilt boundaries (with {\Sigma} values less than 10) will fail to capture polycrystalline grain boundary environments, and thus lead to incorrect quantitative and qualitative insights into their behavior.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of whether using high-symmetry symmetric tilt grain boundaries (STGBs) in polycrystalline materials can represent the real grain boundary environment of polycrystals and to explore the effectiveness of these models in simulating grain boundary behavior.

Specifically, the paper questions the current widespread practice of using high-symmetry coincident site lattice (CSL) grain boundaries as representatives of the complex grain boundaries in polycrystals. The study finds that highly symmetric tilt grain boundaries with low Σ values (less than 10) fail to capture the real grain boundary environment in polycrystalline materials, leading to incorrect qualitative and quantitative understanding of their behavior. For example, in the phenomenon of solute segregation, these models cannot accurately reflect the characteristics of polycrystalline grain boundaries.

By comparing different types of grain boundary structures and their properties, the paper points out that only by increasing the Σ value (from 10 to 100) can the atomic environment space be better covered. However, such high Σ value grain boundaries are too costly for quantum-precision simulation methods (such as density functional theory). Therefore, the paper emphasizes the need to develop new tools and techniques to directly study the grain boundary environment in polycrystalline materials.