Dust Formation in Common Envelope Binary Interaction -- I: 3D Simulations Using the Bowen Approximation

Miguel González-Bolívar,Luis C. Bermúdez-Bustamante,Orsola De Marco,Lionel Siess,Daniel J. Price,Mansi Kasliwal
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stad3748
2024-04-14
Abstract:We carried out 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of the common envelope binary interaction using the approximation of Bowen to calculate the dust opacity in order to investigate the resulting dust-driven accelerations. We have simulated two types of binary star: a 1.7 and a 3.7 $M_{\odot}$ thermally-pulsating, asymptotic giant branch stars with a 0.6 $M_{\odot}$ companion. We carried out simulations using both an ideal gas and a tabulated equations of state, with the latter considering the recombination energy of the envelope. We found that the dust-driven wind leads to a relatively small increase in the unbound gas, with the effect being smaller for the tabulated equation of state simulations and for the more massive primary. Dust acceleration does contribute to envelope expansion with only a slightly elongated morphology, if we believe the results from the tabulated equation of state as more reliable. The Bowen opacities in the outer envelopes of the two models, at late times, are large enough that the photosphere of the post-inspiral object is about ten times larger compared to the same without accounting for the dust opacities. As such, the prediction of the appearance of the transient would change substantially if dust is included.
Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,Astrophysics of Galaxies
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the dust formation in common - envelope binary star interactions and its impact on the envelope dynamics. Specifically, through three - dimensional smoothed - particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations, the researchers used the Bowen approximation to calculate the dust opacity and explored the effect of dust - driven acceleration. The paper focuses on two types of binary star systems: one is a system composed of a 1.7 - solar - mass thermally - pulsing asymptotic giant branch (TP - AGB) star and a 0.6 - solar - mass companion star, and the other is a system composed of a 3.7 - solar - mass TP - AGB star and a 0.6 - solar - mass companion star. The researchers carried out simulations using the ideal gas equation and the tabular equation of state. The latter takes into account the recombination energy of the envelope. The main objective is to evaluate the impact of dust - driven on the envelope expansion and the changes in the appearance prediction of these events when considering the dust opacity. ### Main problem points: 1. **Impact of dust formation**: Study how dust formation affects the dynamic process of the common envelope, especially whether the dust - driven wind will lead to more unbound gas. 2. **Envelope expansion**: Evaluate the specific contribution of dust acceleration to the envelope expansion, especially the morphological changes. 3. **Changes in optical properties**: Explore the impact of dust formation on the optical properties of matter, thereby changing the observational characteristics of these events. 4. **Impact of different equations of state**: Compare the simulation results using the ideal gas equation and the tabular equation of state (taking into account the recombination energy), and evaluate the impact of different equations of state on dust formation and envelope dynamics. ### Research methods: - **Simulation setup**: Use three - dimensional smoothed - particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations combined with the Bowen approximation to calculate the dust opacity. - **Model selection**: Simulate two different binary star systems, namely TP - AGB stars with 1.7 - solar - mass and 3.7 - solar - mass respectively, and each system contains a 0.6 - solar - mass companion star. - **Equations of state**: Use the ideal gas equation and the tabular equation of state for simulations respectively, and the latter takes into account the recombination energy of the envelope. ### Key findings: - **Dust - driven wind**: The increase in unbound gas caused by the dust - driven wind is relatively small, especially in the simulation using the tabular equation of state. - **Envelope expansion**: Dust acceleration does promote the expansion of the envelope, but there is only a slight elongation in morphology. - **Impact of opacity**: In the late stage, the Bowen opacity in the outer envelopes of the two models is large enough, so that the photospheric radius of the post - ingress object is about ten times larger than that without considering the dust opacity. - **Prediction of event appearance**: If the dust opacity is considered, the appearance prediction of these transient events will change significantly. ### Conclusion: Dust formation is an important factor in common - envelope binary star interactions, although its impact on the envelope expansion and unbound gas is relatively limited. However, the increase in dust opacity significantly changes the optical properties of these events and has an important impact on the observational characteristics. Therefore, future research needs to further explore the specific mechanisms and effects of dust formation in different parameter spaces.