Toward a new theory of the fractional quantum Hall effect: The many-body spectra and energy gaps at $ν<1$

S. A. Mikhailov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/nano14030297
2023-06-26
Abstract:In a recent paper (<a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2206.05152v4" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.05152v4">arXiv:2206.05152v4</a>), using the exact diagonalization technique, I calculated the energy and other physical properties (electron density, pair correlation function) of a system of $N\le 7$ two-dimensional electrons at the Landau level filling factor $\nu=1/3$, and showed that the variational many-body wave function proposed for this filling factor by Laughlin is far from the true ground state. In this paper I continue to study exact properties of a small ($N\le 7$) system of two-dimensional electrons lying on the lowest Landau level. I analyze the energies and electron densities of the systems with $N\le 7$ electrons continuously as a function of the magnetic field in the range $1/4\lesssim\nu<1$. The physical mechanisms of the appearance of energy gaps in many-particle electron spectra are elucidated. The results obtained clarify the true nature of the ground and excited states of the considered systems.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in the fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE), for the case of filling factor \( \nu < 1 \), the physical mechanisms of the energy spectrum and energy gap of the many - body system. Specifically, the author studied the many - body characteristics of a two - dimensional electron system at the lowest Landau level under a strong magnetic field through the exact diagonalization technique, especially the difference between the Laughlin variational wave function and the real ground state when the filling factor \( \nu = 1/3 \). ### Specific background of the problem 1. **Fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE)**: - FQHE is a quantum phenomenon in which a two - dimensional electron gas exhibits fractional quantization of conductivity under strong magnetic fields and low - temperature conditions. For example, when the filling factor \( \nu = 1/3 \), the Hall resistance \( \rho_{xy} \) will be quantized to \( \frac{3h}{e^2} \), and the longitudinal resistance \( \rho_{xx} \) will have a deep trough. 2. **Limitations of single - particle theory**: - For the case of \( \nu < 1 \), the single - particle theory cannot explain this phenomenon because at this time the Landau levels are highly degenerate and there is no single - particle energy gap. Therefore, a many - body theory is required to explain this phenomenon. 3. **Laughlin wave function**: - Laughlin proposed a variational wave function to describe the ground state when \( \nu = 1/m \) (m is odd). However, the author's previous calculations showed that there are significant differences between the Laughlin wave function and the real ground state. ### Main objectives of the paper - **Accurately calculate many - body properties**: The author calculated many - body properties such as the energy spectrum and electron density of a two - dimensional electron system with \( N \leq 7 \) under different magnetic field intensities through the exact diagonalization method. - **Reveal the physical mechanism of the energy gap**: Studied the emergence mechanism of the energy gap in these systems, especially the behavior in the range of \( 1/4 \lesssim \nu < 1 \). - **Verify the validity of the Laughlin wave function**: By comparing the energy and electron density of the Laughlin wave function and the real ground state, further verified the limitations of the Laughlin wave function in describing real systems. ### Main findings - **Shapes of the ground state and excited states**: For systems with \( N \leq 5 \), the electron density shows a ring - like distribution; while for systems with \( N \geq 6 \), in addition to the ring - like distribution, an additional density maximum will appear in the center. - **Behavior of the energy gap**: As the magnetic field changes, the energy gap will oscillate and disappear at certain magnetic field points, while remaining finite in other intervals. - **Differences between the Laughlin wave function and the real ground state**: For a system with \( N = 7 \), the energy of the Laughlin wave function is nearly six times higher than that of the real ground state, the electron density difference can reach 70%, and there are also significant differences in the pairing correlation function. In summary, this paper aims to deeply understand the properties of the ground state and excited states of the many - body system in the fractional quantum Hall effect through the exact diagonalization method and reveal the limitations of the Laughlin wave function.