Providing Curative Distribution Grid Flexibility Using Online Feedback Optimization

Florian Klein-Helmkamp,Fabian Böhm,Lukas Ortmann,Alexander Winkens,Florian Schmidtke,Saverio Bolognani,Florian Dörfler,Andreas Ulbig
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ISGTEUROPE56780.2023.10407589
2023-11-06
Abstract:Distribution grid flexibility is discussed as a possible measure in curative system operation, yielding a need for an efficient and robust coordination mechanism for the joint flexibility provision by individual units to the transmission grid. This paper introduces a method to coordinate distribution grid level flexibility as a fast-responding curative measure based on Online Feedback Optimization. We utilize an optimization algorithm in a closed loop with the distribution grid to dispatch set points for active and reactive power to flexibility providing units. The approach is evaluated in an experimental setup, utilizing assets connected to an exemplary low voltage grid. Online Feedback Optimization is found to be both a viable as well as a highly effective approach to coordinate distributed energy resources in real-time curative system operation.
Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems Addressed by the Paper The paper aims to address the issue of curative system operation in power transmission systems. Specifically, when a transmission line is overloaded, rapid response measures need to be taken in a short time to reduce the line load below the Permanent Allowable Transmission Limit (PATL). One possible curative measure is to provide flexibility resources to the Transmission System Operator (TSO) through the Point of Common Coupling (PCC) between the TSO and the Distribution System Operator (DSO). However, these flexibility resources need to be coordinated by the DSO across multiple Flexibility Providing Units (FPU), leading to a demand for efficient and reliable coordination mechanisms. ### Main Contributions This paper proposes a method based on Online Feedback Optimization (OFO) to coordinate and provide active power as a flexibility resource at the PCC. The specific contributions include: 1. **Controller Design**: A controller is designed to optimize the individual feed-in amounts of each FPU in the distribution network while ensuring voltage limits. 2. **Experimental Validation**: The algorithm is implemented in a laboratory setup containing an example low-voltage distribution network. The feasibility and effectiveness of OFO in coordinating curative distribution network flexibility are validated through experiments. 3. **Research Questions**: - How quickly can flexibility resources be provided through OFO? - How do disturbances affect the provision of flexibility resources coordinated by OFO? ### Methods and Results - **Problem Formulation**: The problem of coordinating the requested flexibility resources is formulated as an optimization problem and implemented in the OFO controller. The objective of the optimization problem is to minimize the total active and reactive power provided by the FPUs while satisfying voltage limits and the power capabilities of the FPUs. - **Online Feedback Optimization**: The OFO controller adjusts the next control point by obtaining real-time measurement data from the grid, calculating the gradient of the objective function, and finding the optimal constrained solution through an internal Quadratic Programming (QP). - **Experimental Results**: - **Time Frame**: Within 10 seconds, the OFO controller can fully allocate the requested 14.5 kW of active power to the BESS inverter and PV inverter I, with no tracking error. - **Disturbance Resistance**: In the presence of external disturbances (such as electric vehicle charging), the OFO controller can quickly restore the active power at the PCC to the requested set point and maintain the voltage within the allowable range. ### Conclusion The paper experimentally validates the effectiveness of OFO in coordinating distribution network flexibility in curative system operation. The OFO method has significant advantages in terms of low information requirements and robustness to external disturbances, making it a feasible choice. Future work will explore potential interference issues that may arise during the coordination of multiple OFO controllers.