Group cohesion under asymmetric voting behaviors

Hao Yu,Youjin Wen,Zhehang Xu,Jianlin Zhang,Fanyuan Meng

2023-06-25

Abstract:Cohesion plays a crucial role in achieving collective goals, promoting cooperation and trust, and improving efficiency within social groups. To gain deeper insights into the dynamics of group cohesion, we have extended our previous model of noisy group formation by incorporating asymmetric voting behaviors. Through a combination of theoretical analysis and numerical simulations, we have explored the impact of asymmetric voting noise, the attention decay rate, voter selection methods, and group sizes on group cohesion. For a single voter, we discovered that as the group size approaches infinity, group cohesion converges to $1/(R+1)$, where $R$ represents the ratio of asymmetric voting noise. Remarkably, even in scenarios with extreme voting asymmetry ($R \to \infty$), a significant level of group cohesion can be maintained. Furthermore, when the positive or negative voter's voting noise surpasses or falls below the phase transition point of $R_c=1$, a higher rate of attention decay can lead to increased group cohesion. In the case of multiple voters, a similar phenomenon arises when the attention decay rate reaches a critical point. These insights provide practical implications for fostering effective collaboration and teamwork within growing groups striving to achieve shared objectives.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of understanding the dynamic changes in group cohesion in the presence of asymmetric voting behavior. Specifically, the authors extend their previous model on noise group formation by introducing asymmetric voting behavior and explore the impact of asymmetric voting noise, attention decay rate, voter selection methods, and group size on group cohesion.

### Main Research Questions:
1. **Impact of Asymmetric Voting Behavior on Group Cohesion**: The authors study the changes in group cohesion under different asymmetric voting noise conditions (i.e., different error probabilities of voters with different opinions when voting).
2. **Impact of Attention Decay Rate on Group Cohesion**: The authors examine how group cohesion changes with varying attention decay rates of voters.
3. **Impact of Voter Selection Methods on Group Cohesion**: The authors compare the impact of two different voter selection methods (uniform selection and preferential attachment) on group cohesion.
4. **Impact of Group Size on Group Cohesion**: The authors analyze the trend of group cohesion changes under different group sizes.

### Research Background:
Group cohesion is an important concept in sociology and psychology, relating to the unity and consistency of a group. Understanding group cohesion is crucial for improving team cooperation efficiency and achieving common goals. However, real-world groups often exhibit asymmetric voting behavior and attention decay phenomena. How these factors affect group cohesion is a question worth in-depth study.

### Research Methods:
Combining theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, the authors constructed a model that includes asymmetric voting behavior and attention decay. Through this model, the authors explored the changes in group cohesion under different parameter settings.

### Main Findings:
1. **Single Voter Case**: When the group size approaches infinity, group cohesion tends to a constant \( \frac{1}{R+1} \) determined by the ratio of asymmetric voting noise \( R \). Even in extreme asymmetric voting situations (\( R \to \infty \)), the group can still maintain a certain level of cohesion.
2. **Multiple Voters Case**: When the attention decay rate reaches a critical point, group cohesion increases.
3. **Impact of Attention Decay Rate**: In some cases, a higher attention decay rate can enhance group cohesion.

### Practical Significance:
These research results provide a theoretical basis for promoting effective cooperation and team building. Especially in ever-expanding groups, maintaining and enhancing group cohesion has important practical value.

### Conclusion:
By introducing asymmetric voting behavior and attention decay, the authors provide a more realistic group dynamics model, helping to deeply understand the dynamic mechanisms of group cohesion and its social impact. These findings not only enrich the research on group cohesion but also provide valuable references for practical team management.