The Impact of Customer Online Satisfaction on Stock Returns: Evidence from the E-commerce Reviews in China

Zhi Su,Danni Wu,Zhenkun Zhou,Junran Wu,Libo Yin

2023-06-21

Abstract:This paper investigates the significance of consumer opinions in relation to value in China's A-share market. By analyzing a large dataset comprising over 18 million product reviews by customers on <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://JD.com" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>, we demonstrate that sentiments expressed in consumer reviews can influence stock returns, indicating that consumer opinions contain valuable information that can impact the stock market. Our findings show that Customer Negative Sentiment Tendency (CNST) and One-Star Tendency (OST) have a negative effect on expected stock returns, even after controlling for firm characteristics such as market risk, illiquidity, idiosyncratic volatility, and asset growth. Further analysis reveals that the predictive power of CNST is stronger in firms with high sentiment conditions, growth companies, and firms with lower accounting transparency. We also find that CNST negatively predicts revenue surprises, earnings surprises, and cash flow shocks. These results suggest that online satisfaction derived from big data analysis of customer reviews contains novel information about firms' fundamentals.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the impact of consumer online reviews on stock returns, particularly in the context of the Chinese A-share market. By analyzing over 18 million product reviews on JD.com, the researchers aim to reveal how consumer opinions influence stock market performance.

Specifically, the objectives of the paper can be summarized as follows:

1. **Examine the value of consumer opinions**: Investigate whether consumer reviews on e-commerce platforms contain valuable information about future cash flows and stock returns.

2. **Analyze the relationship between consumer sentiment indicators and stock returns**: Construct indicators such as Consumer Negative Sentiment Tendency (CNST) and One-Star Rating Tendency (OST) to explore the negative correlation between these indicators and expected stock returns.

3. **Explore the changes in the predictive ability of consumer sentiment**: Discover that CNST has stronger predictive power under high sentiment conditions, in growth companies, and in companies with lower accounting transparency.

4. **Evaluate the impact of consumer sentiment on other financial indicators**: Further analysis shows that CNST can predict key financial events such as revenue surprises, earnings surprises, and cash flow shocks.

In summary, the core issue the paper attempts to address is whether the emotions and attitudes reflected in consumer online reviews can effectively predict a company's future cash flows and stock market performance, and whether this predictive ability varies among different types of companies.