Abstract:Healthcare data are inherently multimodal, including electronic health records (EHR), medical images, and multi-omics data. Combining these multimodal data sources contributes to a better understanding of human health and provides optimal personalized healthcare. The most important question when using multimodal data is how to fuse them—a field of growing interest among researchers. Advances in artificial intelligence (AI) technologies, particularly machine learning (ML), enable the fusion of these different data modalities to provide multimodal insights. To this end, in this scoping review, we focus on synthesizing and analyzing the literature that uses AI techniques to fuse multimodal medical data for different clinical applications. More specifically, we focus on studies that only fused EHR with medical imaging data to develop various AI methods for clinical applications. We present a comprehensive analysis of the various fusion strategies, the diseases and clinical outcomes for which multimodal fusion was used, the ML algorithms used to perform multimodal fusion for each clinical application, and the available multimodal medical datasets. We followed the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews) guidelines. We searched Embase, PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar to retrieve relevant studies. After pre-processing and screening, we extracted data from 34 studies that fulfilled the inclusion criteria. We found that studies fusing imaging data with EHR are increasing and doubling from 2020 to 2021. In our analysis, a typical workflow was observed: feeding raw data, fusing different data modalities by applying conventional machine learning (ML) or deep learning (DL) algorithms, and finally, evaluating the multimodal fusion through clinical outcome predictions. Specifically, early fusion was the most used technique in most applications for multimodal learning (22 out of 34 studies). We found that multimodality fusion models outperformed traditional single-modality models for the same task. Disease diagnosis and prediction were the most common clinical outcomes (reported in 20 and 10 studies, respectively) from a clinical outcome perspective. Neurological disorders were the dominant category (16 studies). From an AI perspective, conventional ML models were the most used (19 studies), followed by DL models (16 studies). Multimodal data used in the included studies were mostly from private repositories (21 studies). Through this scoping review, we offer new insights for researchers interested in knowing the current state of knowledge within this research field.

A Survey of Multimodal Information Fusion for Smart Healthcare: Mapping the Journey from Data to Wisdom

Advancing healthcare through multimodal data fusion: a comprehensive review of techniques and applications

A comprehensive survey on multimodal medical signals fusion for smart healthcare systems

Deep Learning Based Multimodal Biomedical Data Fusion: an Overview and Comparative Review

A Survey on Multimodal Data-Driven Smart Healthcare Systems: Approaches and Applications

Artificial intelligence-based methods for fusion of electronic health records and imaging data

Multimodal Machine Learning in Precision Health

Multimodal Medical Image Fusion Towards Future Research: A Review

Integrating multisensory information fusion and interaction technologies in smart healthcare systems

A Review of Multimodal Medical Image Fusion Techniques

A Comprehensive Survey on Deep Learning Multi-Modal Fusion: Methods, Technologies and Applications

Multimodal Medical Image Fusion: The Perspective of Deep Learning

Multimodal deep learning for biomedical data fusion: a review

Multimodal Learning for Multi-Omics: A Survey

Deep Multi-modal Fusion of Image and Non-image Data in Disease Diagnosis and Prognosis: A Review

Multi-Modal Data Fusion in Enhancing Human-Machine Interaction for Robotic Applications: A Survey

A Comprehensive Review of Multimodal Medical Image Fusion Techniques

A review of deep learning-based information fusion techniques for multimodal medical image classification

Use of Multi-Modal Data and Machine Learning to Improve Cardiovascular Disease Care

Multimodal Medical Image Fusion Techniques – A Review

Has Multimodal Learning Delivered Universal Intelligence in Healthcare? A Comprehensive Survey