Model-based versus model-free feeding control and water quality monitoring for fish growth tracking in aquaculture systems

Fahad Aljehani,Ibrahima N'Doye,Taous-Meriem Laleg-Kirati
2023-06-14
Abstract:The high concentration level of the environmental factors, such as a high ammonia concentration and pH level, affect the water quality, affecting fish's survival and mass death. Therefore, there is a critical need to develop control strategies to determine optimal, efficient, and reliable feeding and water quality monitoring processes. In this paper, we revisit the representative fish growth model describing the total biomass change by incorporating the fish population density and mortality. Since the measurement data of the total biomass and population from the aquaculture systems are limited and difficult to obtain, we validate the new dynamic population model with the individual fish growth data for tracking control purposes. We specifically focus on relative feeding as a manipulated variable to design traditional and optimal control to track the desired weight reference within the sub-optimal temperature and dissolved oxygen profiles under different levels of unionized ammonia exposure. Then, we propose a Q-learning approach that learns an optimal feeding control policy from the simulated data of the fish growth weight trajectories while managing the ammonia effects. The proposed Q-learning feeding control prevents fish mortality and achieves good tracking errors of the fish weight under the different levels of unionized ammonia. However, it maintains a relative food consumption that potentially underfeeds the fish. Finally, we propose an optimal algorithm that optimizes the feeding and water quality of the dynamic fish population growth process. We also show that the model predictive control decreases fish mortality and reduces food consumption in all different cases of unionized ammonia exposure.
Systems and Control
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to reduce operating costs and fish losses in aquaculture systems through advanced control strategies, improve growth and production efficiency, and thus promote fish welfare and health. Specifically, the paper focuses on two key elements, namely monitoring water quality and controlling feeding, in order to balance fish productivity and shape the life history of fish. Currently, most fish - feeding processes are carried out manually at different stages and rely on time - consuming and difficult - to - operate artificial judgments. Therefore, it is crucial to develop control strategies that can determine the optimal, efficient and reliable feeding and water - quality monitoring processes. The paper proposes a model - based and model - free feeding control method as well as a water - quality monitoring method for tracking fish growth. The main research contents include: 1. **Establishing a fish - population growth model**: The paper re - examines the representative fish - population growth model that describes the change in total biomass, which combines fish - population density and mortality. Due to the limited and difficult - to - obtain measurement data of total biomass and population data from aquaculture systems, the paper uses the growth data of individual fish to validate the new dynamic population model for tracking - control purposes. 2. **Relative feeding as a control variable**: Pay special attention to relative feeding as a manipulated variable, and design traditional and optimal controls to track the desired weight reference values within sub - optimal temperature and dissolved - oxygen profiles at different non - ionic ammonia exposure levels. 3. **Q - learning algorithm**: Propose a Q - learning method that learns the optimal feeding control strategy from the simulated fish - population growth weight - trajectory data while managing the impact of ammonia. The proposed Q - learning feeding control can prevent fish death and achieve a good fish - weight tracking error at different levels of non - ionic ammonia exposure. However, it maintains a relatively low food consumption, which may lead to over - feeding of fish. 4. **Optimal algorithm**: Finally, the paper proposes an optimization algorithm to optimize feeding and water quality in the dynamic fish - population growth process. The paper also shows that model - predictive control can reduce fish death and food consumption, which is applicable to all different levels of non - ionic ammonia exposure situations. Overall, this paper aims to improve the efficiency and sustainability of aquaculture systems through optimizing feeding and water - quality control strategies.