Germany's nationwide travel experiment in 2022: public transport for 9 Euro per month -- First findings of an empirical study

Allister Loder,Fabienne Cantner,Lennart Adenaw,Nico Nachtigall,David Ziegler,Felix Gotzler,Markus B. Siewert,Stefan Wurster,Sebastian Goerg,Markus Lienkamp,Klaus Bogenberger

2023-06-14

Abstract:In spring 2022, the German federal government agreed on a set of policy measures that aimed at reducing households' financial burden resulting from a recent price increase, especially in energy and mobility. These included among others, a nationwide public transport ticket for 9~Euro per month for three months in June, July, and August 2022. In transport policy research this is an almost unprecedented behavioral experiment. It allows us to study not only behavioral responses in mode choice and induced demand but also to assess the effectiveness of these instruments. We observe this natural experiment with a three-wave survey and a smartphone-based travel diary with passive tracking on an initial sample of 2,261 participants with a focus on the Munich metropolitan region. This area is chosen as it offers a variety of mode options with a dense and far-reaching public transport network that even provides good access to many leisure destinations. The app has been providing data from 756 participants until the end of September, the three-wave survey by 1,402, and the app and the three waves by 637 participants. In this paper, we report on the study design, the recruitment and study participation as well as the impacts of the policy measures on the self-reported and app-observed travel behavior; we present results on consumer choices for a successor ticket to the 9-Euro-Ticket that started in May 2023. We find a substantial shift in the modal share towards public transport from the car in our sample during the 9-Euro-Ticket period in travel distance (around 5 %) and in trip frequency (around 7 %). The mobility outcomes of the 9-Euro-Ticket however provide evidence that cheap public transport as a policy instrument does not suffice to incentive sustainable travel behavior choices and that other policy instruments are required in addition.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Address

The paper primarily explores the impact of a nationwide transportation policy experiment in Germany in 2022—the "9 Euro Monthly Ticket"—on public travel behavior. Specifically:

1. **Policy Background**:
- In the spring of 2022, the German federal government introduced a series of measures to alleviate the economic burden on households, including a nationwide public transportation discount ticket priced at only 9 euros per month for a period of 3 months (June to August 2022).
- This policy aimed to address the cost of living crisis caused by the geopolitical crisis in Ukraine and to promote the use of public transportation post-COVID-19 pandemic.

2. **Research Design**:
- Researchers conducted a natural experiment through three surveys and a smartphone application, collecting travel data from 2,261 participants in the Munich metropolitan area.
- Data collection included self-reported changes in travel behavior as well as actual travel data automatically recorded by the mobile app.

3. **Research Questions**:
- What changes occurred in people's travel behavior during the "9 Euro Monthly Ticket" period?
- Which demographic groups experienced the most significant changes?
- How did people ultimately perceive the value of this discount ticket?

4. **Preliminary Findings**:
- In the sample, the proportion of public transportation as a mode of travel increased by approximately 5%, and travel frequency increased by about 7%.
- However, cheap public transportation as a single policy tool is not sufficient to incentivize sustainable travel behavior; other supporting policies are needed.

In summary, the paper attempts to evaluate the effectiveness of the "9 Euro Monthly Ticket" policy through empirical research and to explore its implications for future sustainable travel policy formulation.